| Centricity | .521 | #212 of 1313 |
| Breadth | .436 | #504 of 1329 |
| Metalism | .000 | #442 of 1329 |
| Centricity | .541 | #99 of 453 |
| Metalism | .000 | #115 of 457 |
| .268 | 8 | Shea Serrano · 2013 |
| .227 | 11 | Abe Beame · 2013 |
| .188 | 10 | Aylin Zafar · 2013 |
| .188 | 10 | Brittany Spanos · 2013 |
| .180 | 6 | Mark J. Lepage · 2013 |
| .174 | 6 | Kye Stephenson · 2013 |
| .174 | 6 | Ryan Patrick · 2013 |
| .168 | 9 | Forrest Wickman · 2013 |
| .168 | 9 | Kathy Iandoli · 2013 |
| .158 | 9 | Rembert Browne · 2013 |
| .157 | 9 | Simon Vozick-Levinson · 2013 |
| .152 | 9 | Sowmya Krishnamurthy · 2013 |
| .133 | 8 | Kyle Kramer · 2013 |
| .119 | 6 | Franklin Paul · 2013 |
| .118 | 8 | Jim Macnie · 2013 |
| .110 | 7 | James Montgomery · 2013 |
| .108 | 6 | Calum Marsh · 2013 |
| .106 | 7 | Adam Graham · 2013 |
| .106 | 7 | Al Choman · 2013 |
| .106 | 7 | Chris Molanphy · 2013 |
| Centricity | .558 | #57 of 693 |
| Metalism | .000 | #140 of 700 |
| Album | Points | Other Votes |
| Jay-Z and Kanye West · Watch the Throne | 15 | 104 |
| Adele · 21 | 10 | 85 |
| Drake · Take Care | 10 | 80 |
| The Roots · Undun | 10 | 59 |
| Frank Ocean · Nostalgia, Ultra | 10 | 53 |
| Beyoncé · 4 | 10 | 45 |
| Kendrick Lamar · Section.80 | 10 | 27 |
| Britney Spears · Femme Fatale | 10 | 23 |
| J. Cole · Cole World: The Sideline Story | 10 | 7 |
| .458 | 19 | Carl Chery · 2011 |
| .406 | 19 | Makkada B. Selah · 2011 |
| .343 | 16 | Adam Graham · 2011 |
| .314 | 15 | Joe Colly · 2011 |
| .274 | 14 | Andy Hutchins · 2011 |
| .272 | 13 | Sowmya Krishnamurthy · 2011 |
| .271 | 13 | Franklin Paul · 2011 |
| .271 | 13 | Nicole Frehsee · 2011 |
| .260 | 12 | Trent Fitzgerald · 2011 |
| .253 | 13 | Joey Daniewicz · 2011 |
| .253 | 12 | Ru Johnson · 2011 |
| .243 | 12 | Abe Beame · 2011 |
| .237 | 12 | James Montgomery · 2011 |
| .228 | 12 | Kyle Kramer · 2011 |
| .228 | 12 | Tom Breihan · 2011 |
| .226 | 8 | Preston Jones · 2011 |
| .217 | 12 | Sean Fennessey · 2011 |
| .216 | 11 | Ken Capobianco · 2011 |
| .211 | 11 | Ryan Dombal · 2011 |
| .205 | 10 | Joey Guerra · 2011 |
| Centricity | .595 | #75 of 699 |
| Metalism | .000 | #121 of 712 |
| .343 | 11 | Damien Lemon · 2010 |
| .290 | 11 | Kye Stephenson · 2010 |
| .288 | 14 | Jozen Cummings · 2010 |
| .284 | 14 | Kem Poston · 2010 |
| .281 | 14 | Ken Capobianco · 2010 |
| .272 | 14 | Abe Beame · 2010 |
| .261 | 13 | Ru Johnson · 2010 |
| .245 | 12 | Shawn White · 2010 |
| .240 | 12 | Evan Serpick · 2010 |
| .236 | 12 | Rob Sheffield · 2010 |
| .233 | 12 | Franklin Paul · 2010 |
| .229 | 12 | Alvin Aqua Boogie Blanco · 2010 |
| .222 | 12 | Andy Wang · 2010 |
| .221 | 11 | Scott Mervis · 2010 |
| .214 | 11 | Michael Gallucci · 2010 |
| .211 | 11 | Bill O'Neill · 2010 |
| .202 | 10 | Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2010 |
| .201 | 11 | Zach Baron · 2010 |
| .199 | 11 | Sean Fennessey · 2010 |
| .189 | 8 | Miles Marshall Lewis · 2010 |
| Centricity | .404 | #155 of 683 |
| Metalism | .000 | #161 of 697 |
| .363 | 15 | Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2009 |
| .319 | 14 | Rodney Dugue · 2009 |
| .240 | 11 | Roy Trakin · 2009 |
| .235 | 11 | Marcello Carlin · 2009 |
| .228 | 10 | Tracy Hopkins · 2009 |
| .219 | 11 | Damien Lemon · 2009 |
| .211 | 10 | David Ritter · 2009 |
| .205 | 10 | Andy Wang · 2009 |
| .196 | 10 | Robert Morast · 2009 |
| .189 | 10 | Ian Steaman · 2009 |
| .189 | 9 | Bob Grossweiner · 2009 |
| .186 | 9 | Tom Lane · 2009 |
| .182 | 6 | Kye Stephenson · 2009 |
| .178 | 9 | Michael Gallucci · 2009 |
| .178 | 9 | Scott Mervis · 2009 |
| .169 | 8 | Glenn Gamboa · 2009 |
| .168 | 9 | Steve Smith · 2009 |
| .166 | 8 | Tyler Lewis · 2009 |
| .158 | 8 | Franklin Paul · 2009 |
| .158 | 8 | Michael Endelman · 2009 |
| Centricity | .506 | #77 of 568 |
| Metalism | .000 | #123 of 579 |
| .378 | 18 | Eric Weisbard · 2008 |
| .369 | 17 | Chris Molanphy · 2008 |
| .326 | 15 | Kristal Hawkins · 2008 |
| .318 | 15 | Justin Strout · 2008 |
| .309 | 14 | Preston Jones · 2008 |
| .294 | 14 | Jason Adams · 2008 |
| .293 | 13 | Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2008 |
| .290 | 14 | Steve Knopper · 2008 |
| .286 | 14 | Mikael Wood · 2008 |
| .283 | 14 | Steve Kiviat · 2008 |
| .281 | 13 | Ken Capobianco · 2008 |
| .275 | 12 | Michael Gallucci · 2008 |
| .274 | 13 | Pete Glowatsky · 2008 |
| .270 | 14 | Damien Lemon · 2008 |
| .269 | 13 | Rodney Dugue · 2008 |
| .251 | 11 | Mike Cimicata · 2008 |
| .242 | 12 | Jessica Koslow · 2008 |
| .232 | 11 | J. Anthony Ware · 2008 |
| .221 | 11 | Thomas Golianopoulos · 2008 |
| .214 | 10 | Franklin Paul · 2008 |
| .328 | 43 | Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins |
| .273 | 34 | Damien Lemon |
| .257 | 28 | Rodney Dugue |
| .250 | 21 | Eric Weisbard |
| .245 | 35 | Abe Beame |
| .235 | 19 | Carl Chery |
| .227 | 25 | Justin Strout |
| .206 | 42 | James Montgomery |
| .201 | 27 | Kye Stephenson |
| .200 | 24 | Adam Graham |
| .196 | 41 | Sean Fennessey |
| .190 | 57 | Franklin Paul |
| .185 | 32 | Ru Johnson |
| .183 | 32 | Alvin Aqua Boogie Blanco |
| .182 | 53 | Ken Capobianco |
| .182 | 35 | Kristal Hawkins |
| .181 | 33 | Andy Wang |
| .178 | 46 | Makkada B. Selah |
| .178 | 18 | Miles Marshall Lewis |
| .178 | 15 | Jozen Cummings |