This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Holly Gleason
Overall
Centricity.256#794 of 1313
Breadth.712#113 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.456#180 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
David Bowie · Blackstar10208
Beyoncé · Lemonade10179
Leonard Cohen · You Want It Darker1080
Drive-By Truckers · American Band1055
Miranda Lambert · The Weight of These Wings1032
Aubrie Sellers · New City Blues102
Aaron Lee Tasjan · Silver Tears101
Elizabeth Cook · Exodus of Venus101
John Prine · For Better, or Worse101
Hayes Carll · Lovers & Leavers100
SongOther Votes
Beyoncé · "Formation"98
Miranda Lambert · "Vice"18
Margo Price · "Hurtin' (on the Bottle)"8
Calvin Harris (ft. Rihanna) · "This Is What You Came For"5
Eric Church (ft. Rhiannon Giddens) · "Kill a Word"3
Lukas Graham · "7 Years"3
Justin Bieber · "Love Yourself"2
Hard Working Americans · "Dope Is Dope"0
Kenny Chesney · "Noise"0
Todd Snider · "Hey Pretty Boy"0

Similar Ballots
.26413Jon Bream · 2016
.26113Chris Willman · 2016
.25713Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2016
.25012Michael Gallucci · 2016
.24912Amy McCarthy · 2016
.21511Bob Townsend · 2016
.20211Brian Ives · 2016
.17710Alan Light · 2016
.1679J. Anthony Ware · 2016
.1589Seth Mnookin · 2016
.1429Mark Zepezauer · 2016
.1366Steve Klinge · 2016
.1358James Barber · 2016
.1356Charles R. Cross · 2016
.1356Tim Riley · 2016
.1349Dan DeLuca · 2016
.1346Bill Holdship · 2016
.1346Larry King · 2016
.1288Edna Gundersen · 2016
.1288Joey Hood · 2016
2014 original ballot
Centricity.344#247 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
D'Angelo · Black Messiah10162
Sturgill Simpson · Metamodern Sounds in Country Music1077
Leonard Cohen · Popular Problems1028
Lucinda Williams · Down Where the Spirit Meets the Bone1016
Robert Plant · Lullaby and...The Ceaseless Roar1015
Sam Smith · In the Lonely Hour1012
Nikki Lane · All or Nothin'108
Robert Ellis · The Lights From the Chemical Plant104
Benmont Tench · You Should Be So Lucky101
(various artists) · WHILE NO ONE WAS LOOKING: 20 YEARS OF BLOODSHOT100
SongOther Votes
Taylor Swift · "Shake It Off"52
Meghan Trainor · "All About That Bass"23
Hozier · "Take Me to Church"16
Maddie & Tae · "Girl in a Country Song"14
Nick Jonas · "Jealous"2
B.o.B · "John Doe"0
Jackson Browne · "Which Side?"0
Leonard Cohen · "Slow"0
Nikki Lane · "Sleep With a Stranger"0
Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers · "American Dream Plan B"0

Similar Ballots
.21610Jon Bream · 2014
.20210Paul Robicheau · 2014
.19510Brian McManus · 2014
.19310Alan Light · 2014
.19211Ellis Widner · 2014
.19210L. Kent Wolgamott · 2014
.1918Leslie Berman · 2014
.1597Carlo Wolff · 2014
.1566Larry King · 2014
.1478Gary Graff · 2014
.1378Wayne Bledsoe · 2014
.1348Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2014
.1327Tom Lane · 2014
.1317Bob Grossweiner · 2014
.1277Roy Trakin · 2014
.1267Glenn Gamboa · 2014
.1237Andrea Domanick · 2014
.1227Rick Mitchell · 2014
.1196James Rodgers · 2014
.1157Brent Baldwin · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.187#313 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Patty Griffin · American Kid204
Eminem · The Marshall Mathers LP 21214
Jason Isbell · Southeastern1133
Mavis Staples · One True Vine105
Dan Baird and Homemade Sin · Circus Life100
Beyoncé · Beyoncé856
(various artists) · Songs for Slim81
Mavericks · In Time77
Kings of Leon · Mechanical Bull76
Guy Clark · My Favorite Picture of You70
SongOther Votes
Lorde · "Royals"75
Haim · "The Wire"58
Robin Thicke (ft. T.I. and Pharrell) · "Blurred Lines"39
Miley Cyrus · "Wrecking Ball"22
Kacey Musgraves · "Follow Your Arrow"21
Janelle Monáe (ft. Erykah Badu) · "Q.U.E.E.N."18
Macklemore & Ryan Lewis (ft. Mary Lambert) · "Same Love"11
Eric Church · "The Outsiders"1
Guy Clark · "My Favorite Picture of You"0
Lee Ann Womack · "Let'Em In"0

Similar Ballots
.37116Jon Bream · 2013
.28213Alan Light · 2013
.21810Lola Emanuelli · 2013
.21610L. Kent Wolgamott · 2013
.20110James Montgomery · 2013
.18910Andrew Dansby · 2013
.1839Tom Lane · 2013
.1728Michael Gallucci · 2013
.1719Adam Graham · 2013
.1679Brittany Spanos · 2013
.1678Roy Trakin · 2013
.1669Richard Torres · 2013
.1649Bob Grossweiner · 2013
.1618Travis Hay · 2013
.1609Rob Harvilla · 2013
.1598Ken Rayes · 2013
.1588Ben Salmon · 2013
.1458Bill Holdship · 2013
.1395Jeff Vrabel · 2013
.1368Dan Kois · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.122#368 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Dr. John · Locked Down1231
Bettye LaVette · Thankful N' Thoughtful127
(various artists) · Kin: Songs by Mary Karr & Rodney Crowell123
Black Keys · El Camino121
Bob Dylan · Tempest1032
The Lumineers · The Lumineers105
Patti Smith · Banga88
Betty Wright & the Roots · Betty Write: The Movie80
Dirty Guvnahs · Somewhere Beneath These Southern Skies80
Tom Waits · Bad As Me80
SongOther Votes
Frank Ocean · "Thinkin' 'Bout You"46
Taylor Swift · "We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together"42
Fun. (ft. Janelle Monae) · "We Are Young"22
Ke$ha · "Die Young"15
Kacey Musgraves · "Merry Go 'Round"14
The Lumineers · "Ho Hey"8
Alan Jackson · "So You Don't Have to Love Me Anymore"3
Bonnie Raitt · "Not Cause I Wanted To"2
Eli Young Band · "Even If It Breaks Your Heart"0
Jack White · "Freedom at 21"0

Similar Ballots
.22711Bob Grossweiner · 2012
.1779Leslie Berman · 2012
.1769Ken Rayes · 2012
.1739L. Kent Wolgamott · 2012
.1639David Cantwell · 2012
.1576Thor Christensen · 2012
.1528Derek Paiva · 2012
.1358Jon Bream · 2012
.1325Steve Hochman · 2012
.1266Larry King · 2012
.1207Phil Gallo · 2012
.1177Michael Deeds · 2012
.1138Ellis Widner · 2012
.1105Jeff Tamarkin · 2012
.1035Preston Jones · 2011
.1016Daniel Durchholz · 2012
.1016Nick Duerden · 2012
.0956James Rodgers · 2012
.0896Joey Daniewicz · 2012
.0894David Menconi · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.451#155 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Tom Waits · Bad As Me1095
Adele · 211085
Paul Simon · So Beautiful or So What1060
The Roots · Undun1059
Black Keys · El Camino1053
Pistol Annies · Hell on Heels1042
Dum Dum Girls · Only in Dreams1023
Betty Wright & the Roots · Betty Wright: The Movie103
Matraca Berg · The Dreaming Fields101
Nathan Bell · Black Crow Blue100
SongOther Votes
Adele · "Rolling in the Deep"109
Rihanna (ft. Calvin Harris) · "We Found Love"29
Lady Gaga · "Born This Way"19
Civil Wars · "Barton Hollow"6
Ronnie Dunn · "Cost of Livin'"2
Band Perry · "If I Die Young"1
Jimmy Fallon & Justin Timberlake · "History of Rap"1
Alison Krauss & Union Station · "Paper Airplanes"0
Black Stone Cherry · "Blame It on the Boom Boom"0
Stoney LaRue · "Velvet"0

Similar Ballots
.30710Preston Jones · 2011
.24112Bob Grossweiner · 2011
.2409Salvatore Caputo · 2011
.23912Jon Bream · 2011
.21811George Varga · 2011
.20310Alan Light · 2011
.19810Chris Herrington · 2011
.1849Derek Paiva · 2011
.1837Billy Altman · 2011
.1769Ted Cox · 2011
.1709Kathy Iandoli · 2011
.1629Daniel Durchholz · 2011
.1568Clover Hope · 2011
.1556Andrew Downing · 2011
.1548J. Anthony Ware · 2011
.1546Stephen Haag · 2011
.1486Carlo Wolff · 2011
.1478Chris Willman · 2011
.1478Scott Mervis · 2011
.1476Paul Robicheau · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.187#467 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Ray Wylie Hubbard · A) Enlightenment, B) Endarkenment, C) There Is No C141
Guy Clark · Some Days the Song Writes You140
Bruce Springsteen · The Promise1333
Patty Griffin · Downtown Church1211
Cee Lo Green · The Lady Killer1143
Black Keys · Brothers988
Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers · Mojo99
Alejandro Escovedo · Street Songs of Love74
Allison Moorer · Crows60
Jamey Johnson · The Guitar Song547
SongOther Votes
Cee Lo Green · "Fuck You!"186
Eminem (ft. Rihanna) · "Love the Way You Lie"27
Katy Perry · "California Gurls"20
B.o.B (ft. Hayley Williams) · "Airplanes"13
Miranda Lambert · "The House That Built Me"11
Band Perry · "If I Die Young"4
Jamey Johnson · "Playing the Part"2
Alex Bevan · "Ringless Man"0
Buddy & Julie Miller · "Chalk"0
Taylor Swift · "Innocent"0

Similar Ballots
.35516Alan Light · 2010
.26712Michael Gallucci · 2010
.23512Bob Grossweiner · 2010
.19410Gary Graff · 2010
.1938Bill Holdship · 2010
.1929Bill O'Neill · 2010
.1827John Milward · 2010
.1789Ken Capobianco · 2010
.1746Preston Jones · 2010
.1729Jon Bream · 2010
.1726Rick Mitchell · 2010
.1719Derek Paiva · 2010
.1618Roy Trakin · 2010
.1596Kevin O'Hare · 2010
.1508Steve Leftridge · 2010
.1488Bobby Reed · 2010
.1476Meredith Ochs · 2010
.1458Tom Lane · 2010
.1437Carlo Wolff · 2010
.1347Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.130#500 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Guy Clark · Some Days the Song Writes You201
Maxwell · BLACKsummers'night1048
Lady Gaga · The Fame/The Fame Monster1025
Buddy & Julie Miller · Written in Chalk1014
Kris Kristofferson · Closer to the Bone106
Diane Birch · Bible Belt102
Matthew Ryan · Dear Lover101
Bill Deasy · Being Normal100
Rosanne Cash · The List523
Willie Nelson and Asleep at the Wheel · Willie and the Wheel54
SongOther Votes
Jay-Z (ft. Alicia Keys) · "Empire State of Mind"88
Lady Gaga · "Poker Face"26
Maxwell · "Pretty Wings"26
Kings of Leon · "Use Somebody"24
Bruce Springsteen · "Working on a Dream"3
Brooks & Dunn · "Indian Summer"0
Garfunkel & Oates · "The Party Took a Turn for the Douche"0
George Strait · "Troubadour"0
John Legend (ft. Andre 3000) · "Green Light"0
Rage Against the Machine · "Killing in the Name"0

Similar Ballots
.2548Jim Bessman · 2009
.1919Tracy Hopkins · 2009
.1869Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2009
.1608Bob Grossweiner · 2009
.1608Clover Hope · 2009
.1538L. Kent Wolgamott · 2009
.1347Tom Lane · 2009
.1325Al Choman · 2009
.1317Roy Trakin · 2009
.1297Charles R. Cross · 2009
.1277Omar Kholeif · 2009
.1235Salvatore Caputo · 2009
.1227Alan Light · 2009
.1227Dave Lindquist · 2009
.1156Jim Farber · 2009
.1106Bill Crandall · 2009
.1036J. Anthony Ware · 2009
.1016Andy Wang · 2009
.0974Holly George-Warren · 2009
.0904Dan Ouellette · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.167#399 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Erykah Badu · New Amerykah, Pt. 1: 4th World War1079
Black Keys · Attack & Release1017
Raconteurs · Consolers of the Lonely1016
Mudcrutch · Mudcrutch109
AC/DC · Black Ice106
Rodney Crowell · Sex & Gasoline106
J.D. Souther · If the World Was You102
Lee Ann Womack · Call Me Crazy102
Allison Moorer · Songbird100
Michael Stanley · Just Another Night100
SongOther Votes
Kings of Leon · "Sex on Fire"15
Kid Rock · "All Summer Long"7
Lee Ann Womack · "Last Call"7
Madonna (ft. Justin Timberlake) · "4 Minutes"3
Bruce Springsteen · "Girls in Their Summer Clothes"1
Grace Potter & the Nocturnals · "All Apologies"0
Kenny Chesney · "Better As a Memory"0
Lady Antebellum · "Love Don't Live Here Anymore"0
Randy Houser · "Anything Goes"0
Saving Abel · "Addicted"0

Similar Ballots
.1666Bob Ruggiero · 2008
.1578Gary Graff · 2008
.1335Ben Mitchell · 2008
.1006Paul Robicheau · 2008
.0894Thor Christensen · 2008
.0795Ron Wynn · 2008
.0754Bill Holdship · 2008
.0694Chris M. Junior · 2008
.0644David Cantwell · 2008
.0644Preston Jones · 2008
.0624James Montgomery · 2008
.0624Josh Love · 2008
.0614Dave Herrera · 2008
.0614Thomas Inskeep · 2008
.0604Melissa Maerz · 2008
.0603Bob Grossweiner · 2008
.0583Mark J. Lepage · 2008
.0564Gary Chun · 2008
.0484Mark Zepezauer · 2008
.0484Wes Flexner · 2008
Similar Voters
.26479Jon Bream
.23568Alan Light
.21767Bob Grossweiner
.18464L. Kent Wolgamott
.16924Salvatore Caputo
.16152Michael Gallucci
.15724Carlo Wolff
.15253Stephen Thomas Erlewine
.15056Gary Graff
.15036Preston Jones
.15029Chris Willman
.14950Roy Trakin
.14830Leslie Berman
.14752Tom Lane
.14742Bill Holdship
.14150J. Anthony Ware
.13737Derek Paiva
.13435Geoffrey Himes
.13332Steve Leftridge
.13047Daniel Durchholz
.13047Ellis Widner
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com