| Centricity | .172 | #991 of 1313 |
| Breadth | .667 | #161 of 1329 |
| Metalism | .000 | #442 of 1329 |
| Centricity | .291 | #326 of 542 |
| Metalism | .000 | #75 of 550 |
| Song | Other Votes |
| Beyoncé · "Formation" | 98 |
| Leonard Cohen · "You Want It Darker" | 41 |
| David Bowie · "Lazarus" | 38 |
| Chance the Rapper · "All Night" | 6 |
| .181 | 10 | Seth Mnookin · 2016 |
| .169 | 9 | Jon Bream · 2016 |
| .167 | 9 | Alan Light · 2016 |
| .145 | 8 | Edna Gundersen · 2016 |
| .134 | 8 | Melissa Locker · 2016 |
| .131 | 5 | Mallory O'Donnell · 2016 |
| .130 | 8 | Patrick Rogers · 2016 |
| .126 | 8 | Roy Trakin · 2016 |
| .126 | 7 | Bob Grossweiner · 2016 |
| .123 | 5 | Mike Rowell · 2016 |
| .113 | 7 | Aaron Hillis · 2016 |
| .111 | 5 | Ron Hart · 2016 |
| .109 | 5 | Ashley Zlatopolsky · 2016 |
| .105 | 7 | Kyle McGovern · 2016 |
| .104 | 7 | Zach Schonfeld · 2016 |
| .103 | 7 | E.J. Friedman · 2016 |
| .096 | 7 | Spencer Kornhaber · 2016 |
| .093 | 7 | Adam Kivel · 2016 |
| .091 | 6 | Gabriel Rosenberg · 2016 |
| .091 | 6 | Michael Gallucci · 2016 |
| Centricity | .290 | #283 of 480 |
| Metalism | .000 | #85 of 483 |
| Centricity | .048 | #549 of 601 |
| Metalism | .000 | #102 of 612 |
| Centricity | .034 | #421 of 453 |
| Metalism | .000 | #115 of 457 |
| Song | Other Votes |
| Daft Punk (ft. Pharrell Williams) · "Get Lucky" | 116 |
| Lorde · "Royals" | 75 |
| .123 | 6 | Ted Cox · 2013 |
| .114 | 6 | Dave Lindquist · 2013 |
| .110 | 6 | Randall Grass · 2013 |
| .084 | 4 | Michael Ayers · 2013 |
| .074 | 4 | Serene Dominic · 2013 |
| .070 | 4 | Maureen Miller · 2013 |
| .067 | 4 | Joey Hood · 2013 |
| .066 | 4 | Dan DeLuca · 2013 |
| .064 | 4 | Derek Paiva · 2013 |
| .064 | 4 | James Montgomery · 2013 |
| .064 | 4 | Nick Duerden · 2013 |
| .063 | 4 | @Discographies · 2013 |
| .063 | 4 | Alan Light · 2013 |
| .063 | 4 | Steve Kiviat · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | Adam Graham · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | Eric Danton · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | Eugene Holley, Jr. · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | Jeff Gage · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | Jose Duran · 2013 |
| .062 | 4 | L. Kent Wolgamott · 2013 |
| Centricity | .127 | #362 of 485 |
| Metalism | .000 | #95 of 493 |
| .104 | 6 | Saxon Baird · 2012 |
| .100 | 6 | Mike Greenhaus · 2012 |
| .100 | 4 | Steve Hochman · 2012 |
| .097 | 6 | Ted Cox · 2012 |
| .081 | 5 | Gustavo Turner · 2012 |
| .078 | 5 | Logan K. Young · 2012 |
| .075 | 5 | Nick Green · 2012 |
| .073 | 5 | Eric Danton · 2012 |
| .073 | 5 | Kurt B. Reighley · 2012 |
| .071 | 5 | Anthony Easton · 2012 |
| .068 | 5 | Don Allred · 2012 |
| .068 | 4 | Peter Gerstenzang · 2012 |
| .066 | 4 | Robert Christgau · 2012 |
| .064 | 4 | Richard Skanse · 2012 |
| .064 | 4 | Todd Kristel · 2012 |
| .063 | 4 | Michael Tatum · 2012 |
| .061 | 4 | Marianne Meyer · 2012 |
| .055 | 4 | Kyle Kramer · 2012 |
| .051 | 4 | Anthony Lombardi · 2012 |
| .051 | 4 | Maureen Miller · 2012 |
| .051 | 4 | Rob Michaels · 2012 |
| Centricity | .113 | #567 of 693 |
| Metalism | .000 | #140 of 700 |
| Song | Other Votes |
| Adele · "Rolling in the Deep" | 109 |
| Foster the People · "Pumped Up Kicks" | 38 |
| Rihanna · "Man Down" | 5 |
| Gillian Welch · "Tennessee" | 1 |
| Brad Paisley · "Camouflage" | 0 |
| Simone Felice · "New York Times" | 0 |
| .129 | 7 | George Varga · 2011 |
| .118 | 6 | Derek Paiva · 2011 |
| .118 | 6 | Marianne Meyer · 2011 |
| .117 | 5 | Allen St John · 2011 |
| .112 | 7 | Brent Baldwin · 2011 |
| .109 | 6 | Jon Bream · 2011 |
| .108 | 6 | Chris Molanphy · 2011 |
| .108 | 6 | Ed Condran · 2011 |
| .106 | 6 | Bob Grossweiner · 2011 |
| .105 | 6 | Tom Lane · 2011 |
| .103 | 5 | Steve Baltin · 2011 |
| .101 | 6 | Gary Graff · 2011 |
| .101 | 6 | Mikael Wood · 2011 |
| .099 | 6 | Josh Timmermann · 2011 |
| .087 | 5 | Catherine Lewis · 2011 |
| .087 | 5 | Keith Harris · 2011 |
| .087 | 5 | Ken Rayes · 2011 |
| .087 | 5 | Philip Martin · 2011 |
| .087 | 4 | Thor Christensen · 2011 |
| .086 | 4 | Steve Matteo · 2011 |
| Centricity | .082 | #574 of 699 |
| Metalism | .000 | #121 of 712 |
| Song | Other Votes |
| Robyn · "Don't Fucking Tell Me What to Do" | 3 |
| Centricity | .323 | #245 of 683 |
| Metalism | .000 | #161 of 697 |
| Centricity | .241 | #312 of 568 |
| Metalism | .000 | #123 of 579 |
| .088 | 14 | George Varga |
| .085 | 32 | Bob Grossweiner |
| .080 | 32 | Roy Trakin |
| .078 | 27 | Brent Baldwin |
| .078 | 18 | Steve Hochman |
| .074 | 27 | Ted Cox |
| .072 | 24 | Maureen Miller |
| .071 | 25 | Robert Christgau |
| .071 | 18 | Nate Chinen |
| .068 | 26 | Ken Rayes |
| .067 | 21 | Jason Gubbels |
| .065 | 18 | Christian Hoard |
| .064 | 19 | James Montgomery |
| .063 | 24 | Mike Greenhaus |
| .063 | 22 | Michael Ayers |
| .063 | 10 | Julie Seabaugh |
| .062 | 20 | Derek Paiva |
| .060 | 26 | Marianne Meyer |
| .060 | 25 | Daniel Durchholz |
| .060 | 14 | K Leander Williams |