This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
M.J. Fine
Overall
Centricity.157#1026 of 1313
Breadth.722#95 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.093#440 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
case/lang/veirs · case/lang/veirs208
PJ Harvey · The Hope Six Demolition Project1516
Lucinda Williams · The Ghosts of Highway 20159
Soundwalk Collective & Jesse Paris Smith (ft. Patti Smith) · Killer Road120
Drive-By Truckers · American Band1055
Lucius · Good Grief83
Thao Nguyen With the Get Down Stay Down · A Man Alive57
Bat for Lashes · The Bride54
Laura Mvula · The Dreaming Room54
Haley Bonar · Impossible Dream51
SongOther Votes
Solange · "Cranes in the Sky"63
Mitski · "Your Best American Girl"55
Leonard Cohen · "You Want It Darker"41
Tegan and Sara · "Boyfriend"8
Japanese Breakfast · "Everybody Wants to Love You"5
Beyoncé (ft. Dixie Chicks) · "Daddy Lessons (Remix)"3
case/lang/veirs · "Atomic Number"2
Santigold · "Can't Get Enough of Myself"2
Alice Bag · "He's So Sorry"0
Bleached · "Wednesday Night Melody"0

Similar Ballots
.1518Kory Grow · 2016
.1507Katie Moulton · 2016
.1437Jon LaFollette · 2016
.1367Mike Prevatt · 2016
.1357Josh Timmermann · 2016
.1277Byron Crawford · 2016
.1257Robert Loerzel · 2016
.1247Dan DeLuca · 2016
.1205Larry King · 2016
.1146Jon Bream · 2016
.1106Peter Blackstock · 2016
.1096Edna Gundersen · 2016
.1076Christopher Barton · 2016
.1076J. Anthony Ware · 2016
.1066Mark Zepezauer · 2016
.1056Daniel Kohn · 2016
.1056Gabriel Rosenberg · 2016
.0906Mac Wilson · 2016
.0904Adam Gold · 2016
.0875Stephen Thompson · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.382#208 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Sleater-Kinney · No Cities to Love3091
Screaming Females · Rose Mountain208
Arc Divers · Holding Bodies80
Courtney Barnett · Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit7166
Sonics · This Is the Sonics79
Eleventh Dream Day · Works for Tomorrow71
Hop Along · Painted Shut630
Kacey Musgraves · Pageant Material532
Low · Ones and Sixes517
Jlin · Dark Energy57
SongOther Votes
The Weeknd · "Can't Feel My Face"68
Courtney Barnett · "Pedestrian at Best"52
Adele · "Hello"41
Alessia Cara · "Here"24
Erykah Badu · "Cel U Lar Device"7
Janelle Monae & Wondaland · "Hell You Talmbout"5
Torres · "Strange Hellos"4
The Decemberists · "The Singer Addresses His Audience"1
Adia Victoria · "Howlin' Shame"0
Hemming · "Some of My Friends"0

Similar Ballots
.21911Anders Smith Lindall · 2015
.21310Michael Gallucci · 2015
.1899Melissa Fossum · 2015
.1749Peter Tabakis · 2015
.1729Katie Moulton · 2015
.1648Jeanne Fury · 2015
.1578Stephen Thompson · 2015
.1566Scott Mervis · 2015
.1558Melissa Locker · 2015
.1499Shane Harrison · 2015
.1476Dan Bogosian · 2015
.1468Althea Legaspi · 2015
.1458Dave Lindquist · 2015
.1458Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2015
.1418Sarah Ventre · 2015
.1378Daniel Sargeant · 2015
.1358Caryn Rose · 2015
.1308Steve Reynolds · 2015
.1297Eric Danton · 2015
.1267Hardeep Phull · 2015
.1267Paul Thompson · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.096#499 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Lydia Loveless · Somewhere Else2525
Strand of Oaks · Heal238
Rosanne Cash · The River & the Thread1027
Tacocat · Nvm76
Jessica Lea Mayfield · Make My Head Sing72
Orenda Fink · Blue Dream70
Thurston Moore · The Best Day62
Lee Bains III & the Glory Fires · Dereconstructed57
The Both · The Both55
Lera Lynn · The Avenues50
SongOther Votes
tUnE-yArDs · "Water Fountain"25
Sleater-Kinney · "Bury Our Friends"15
Sharon Van Etten · "Your Love Is Killing Me"14
Ex Hex · "Don't Wanna Lose"7
Lykke Li · "No Rest for the Wicked"6
First Aid Kit · "My Silver Lining"2
Tori Amos · "Trouble's Lament"2
Cadbury Sisters · "Milk"0
First Aid Kit · "Walk Unafraid"0
Rosebuds · "In My Teeth"0

Similar Ballots
.0855Kory Grow · 2014
.0835Althea Legaspi · 2014
.0835Eric Swedlund · 2014
.0835Greg Kot · 2014
.0835Jere Pilapil · 2014
.0825Chris Herrington · 2014
.0804Steve Klinge · 2014
.0774David Goldstein · 2014
.0634Rob Harvilla · 2014
.0614Charles Johnson · 2014
.0603Nicholas Taylor · 2014
.0594Patrick Wall · 2014
.0594Phil Cosores · 2014
.0584Art Tavana · 2014
.0584Sarah Ventre · 2014
.0583Anders Smith Lindall · 2014
.0574Bill O'Neill · 2014
.0574Jon Pareles · 2014
.0574Michael Roffman · 2014
.0554John Tryneski · 2014
.0554John Wenzel · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.183#316 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Basia Bulat · Tall Tall Shadow160
Boy · Mutual Friends151
Lady Lamb the Beekeeper · Ripely Pine144
Sondra Sun-Odeon · Aethera110
Ólöf Arnalds · Sudden Elevation100
Laura Veirs · Warp and Weft92
Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds · Push the Sky Away726
Poppy Ackroyd · Escapement70
Savages · Silence Yourself641
Janelle Monáe · The Electric Lady550
SongOther Votes
Arcade Fire · "Reflektor"26
P!nk (ft. Nate Ruess) · "Just Give Me a Reason"2
Thao Nguyen With the Get Down Stay Down · "We the Common (for Valerie Bolden)"1
Basia Bulat · "Tall Tall Shadow"0
Boy · "Little Numbers"0
Ex Hex · "Hot and Cold"0
Laura Stevenson · "Runner"0
Mount Moriah · "Mirach Temple Holiness"0
pacificUV · "Wolves Again"0
Sallie Ford & the Sound Outside · "They Told Me"0

Similar Ballots
.1135Matt Sebastian · 2013
.1125Zeth Lundy · 2013
.1016Jeff Gage · 2013
.0894Jill Ettinger · 2013
.0844Jennifer Kelly · 2013
.0815Alex Young · 2013
.0805Zach Schonfeld · 2013
.0795Hilary Hughes · 2013
.0794Aaron Hillis · 2013
.0765Ed Masley · 2013
.0735Ellis Widner · 2013
.0624Geoffrey Himes · 2013
.0604Joey Hood · 2013
.0604Serene Dominic · 2013
.0594Jeanne Fury · 2013
.0574Devon Maloney · 2013
.0554Kenneth Partridge · 2013
.0544Harry Burson · 2013
.0544Paul Robicheau · 2013
.0534Brett Koshkin · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.107#378 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Anais Mitchell · Young Man in America193
Alex Winston · King Con130
First Aid Kit · The Lion's Roar1212
Hope for Agoldensummer · Life Inside the Body110
Corin Tucker Band · Kill My Blues108
The dB's · Falling Off the Sky98
Amanda Palmer & the Grand Theft Orchestra · Theatre Is Evil84
Spring Standards · Yellow//gold70
Trophy Wife · Sing What Scares You60
Jack White · Blunderbuss540
SongOther Votes
Gotye (ft. Kimbra) · "Somebody That I Used to Know"30
Fun. (ft. Janelle Monae) · "We Are Young"22
Of Monsters and Men · "Little Talks"6
Gossip · "Get a Job"2
Black Prairie · "How Do You Ruin Me"0
Jan · "Work for the City"0
Megan Reilly · "Old Man and the Bird"0
Mindy Smith · "Closer"0
Rhett Miller · "Out of Love"0
Tori Amos · "Flavor"0

Similar Ballots
.1638Nick Duerden · 2012
.1357Marianne Meyer · 2012
.1136James Rodgers · 2012
.0674Derek Paiva · 2012
.0664Bob Grossweiner · 2012
.0654Glenn Gamboa · 2012
.0654Marc Hirsh · 2012
.0634Lola Emanuelli · 2012
.0634Roy Trakin · 2012
.0624Ken Rayes · 2012
.0624L. Kent Wolgamott · 2012
.0624Ted Cox · 2012
.0614Al Choman · 2012
.0614Barry Walters · 2012
.0614Saul Austerlitz · 2012
.0604Kurt B. Reighley · 2012
.0604Mike Greenhaus · 2012
.0594Phil Gallo · 2012
.0574Gary Graff · 2012
.0574George A. Paul · 2012
.0574Travis Hay · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.136#538 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Wild Flag · Wild Flag1790
R.E.M. · Collapse Into Now1512
Le Butcherettes · Sin Sin Sin126
Rosebuds · Loud Planes Fly Low112
Andrew Lipke · The Plague100
Poly Styrene · Generation Indigo93
Lion Versus · Five Hearts80
Jill Scott · The Light of the Sun76
John Wesley Harding · Sound of His Own Voice62
Lia Ices · Grown Unknown50
SongOther Votes
Adele · "Rolling in the Deep"109
Foster the People · "Pumped Up Kicks"38
The Decemberists · "Down by the Water"6
Low · "Especially Me"4
Foo Fighters · "Dear Rosemary"3
Twilight Singers · "On the Corner"1
Baseball Project · "Don't Call Them Twinkies"0
Keren Ann · "101"0
Meshell Ndegeocello · "Oysters"0
Rebecca Pronsky · "Day of the Dead"0

Similar Ballots
.19510L. Kent Wolgamott · 2011
.1436Allen St John · 2011
.1275Kyle Ryan · 2011
.1245Jim DeRogatis · 2011
.1235Lloyd Sachs · 2011
.1177Gary Graff · 2011
.1176Steve Reynolds · 2011
.1086Ken Rayes · 2011
.1036Tom Lane · 2011
.0896Jim Sullivan · 2011
.0874Eric T Miller · 2011
.0845Derek Paiva · 2011
.0805Nicole Frehsee · 2011
.0775Ted Cox · 2011
.0745Bob Grossweiner · 2011
.0745Marc Hirsh · 2011
.0745Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2011
.0735Charles R. Cross · 2011
.0725Scott Mervis · 2011
.0715Sarah Ventre · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.126#520 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Arcade Fire · The Suburbs20144
Tired Pony · The Place We Ran From151
Evelyn Evelyn · Evelyn Evelyn110
Peggy Sue · Fossils and Other Phantoms110
Anais Mitchell · Hadestown93
Samantha Crain · You (Understood)90
Living Sisters · Love to Live73
Chapin Sisters · Two70
David Byrne & Fatboy Slim · Here Lies Love66
Sea of Bees · Songs for the Ravens50

Similar Ballots
.0614Emily Tartanella · 2010
.0584Marianne Meyer · 2010
.0342Christian John Wikane · 2010
.0333Fred Mills · 2010
.0332Tristram Lozaw · 2010
.0312Kevin Moreau · 2010
.0242Daniel King · 2010
.0222Kristyn Pomranz · 2010
.0212Ben Westhoff · 2010
.0212Gary Chun · 2010
.0212John Bush · 2010
.0212Marc Hirsh · 2010
.0202Alan Ranta · 2010
.0202Lola Emanuelli · 2010
.0192Thomas Hauner · 2010
.0172Jason Gargano · 2010
.0172Max Berry · 2010
.0162Ben Schumer · 2010
.0162Jeff Vrabel · 2010
.0162Jonah Flicker · 2010
.0162Ken Tucker · 2010
.0162Mark J. Lepage · 2010
.0162Martin Cizmar · 2010
.0162Preston Jones · 2010
.0162Rob Trucks · 2010
.0162Ryan Wasoba · 2010
.0162Sam Hockley-Smith · 2010
.0162Steve Horowitz · 2010
.0162Thor Christensen · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.257#315 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Ida Maria · Fortress Round My Heart2016
Carsie Blanton · Buoy180
Bat for Lashes · Two Suns1039
Metric · Fantasies1019
Florence & the Machine · Lungs916
Canadian Invasion · Three Cheers for the Invisible Hand80
Drivin N Cryin · The Great American Bubble Factory80
Strand of Oaks · Leave Ruin71
Neko Case · Middle Cyclone5105
St. Vincent · Actor561

Similar Ballots
.2026Althea Legaspi · 2009
.1758Jennifer Vineyard · 2009
.1758Liz Colville · 2009
.1608Brian Orloff · 2009
.1324Brooke Foster · 2009
.1156Julia Simon · 2009
.1154David Menconi · 2009
.1116Whitney Pastorek · 2009
.1114Joan Anderman · 2009
.1094Jim DeRogatis · 2009
.1076Eric Danton · 2009
.1074Laura Barcella · 2009
.1066Jim Macnie · 2009
.1064Matt Sebastian · 2009
.1054Jay Lustig · 2009
.1044Scott Holter · 2009
.1024Dana Bos · 2009
.1014Jason Ferguson · 2009
.1004MacKenzie Wilson · 2009
.0985Chris Burlingame · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.036#532 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Frida Hyvönen · Silence Is Wild155
CSS · Donkey142
Finest Dearest · Finest Dearest130
Tilly and the Wall · O121
Shondes · The Red Sea110
Thao Nguyen With the Get Down Stay Down · We Brave Bee Stings and All94
Rebecca Pronsky · Departures & Arrivals80
Theresa Andersson · Hummingbird, Go!73
Thee Silver Mt. Zion Memorial Orchesta and Tra-la-La Band · 13 Blues for Thirteen Moons61
Amanda Palmer · Who Killed Amanda Palmer56

Similar Ballots
.0764Robert Loerzel · 2008
.0352Alex Rawls · 2008
.0352Steve Rosen · 2008
.0342Fred Mills · 2008
.0332Eryc Eyl · 2008
.0332Jason Pettigrew · 2008
.0332Ken Scrudato · 2008
.0332Rob O'Connor · 2008
.0332Trevor Fisher · 2008
.0222Sarah Zupko · 2008
.0212David Malitz · 2008
.0212Frank Kogan · 2008
.0202David Cooper Moore · 2008
.0202Deborah Sprague · 2008
.0202Doug Wallen · 2008
.0202Joe Silva · 2008
.0202Josh Freedom du Lac · 2008
.0202Nick Green · 2008
.0192Katherine Silkaitis · 2008
.0192Kurt B. Reighley · 2008
.0192Linda Leseman · 2008
Similar Voters
.11020Katie Moulton
.10335Althea Legaspi
.10134Jennifer Vineyard
.09921Jim DeRogatis
.09628Dan DeLuca
.09233L. Kent Wolgamott
.09033Eric Danton
.09030Jeanne Fury
.08824Max Berry
.08817Gabriel Rosenberg
.08732Brian Orloff
.08716Anders Smith Lindall
.08431Robert Loerzel
.08319Laura Leebove
.08314Peter Tabakis
.08228Michael Gallucci
.07929Marianne Meyer
.07925Steve Klinge
.07829Chris Molanphy
.07727Ted Cox
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com