This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Philip Sherburne
Overall
Centricity.232#854 of 1313
Breadth.789#42 of 1329
Metalism.017#325 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.249#353 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
David Bowie · Blackstar10208
Angel Olsen · My Woman1070
Huerco S. · For Those of You Who Have Never (and Also Those Who Have)108
Elza Soares · The Woman at the End of the World (a Mulher Do Fim Do Mundo)107
Cate Le Bon · Crab Day105
Andrew Pekler · Tristes Tropiques101
Suzanne Kraft · What You Get for Being Young101
Jeff Parker · Slight Freedom100
Masayoshi Fujita & Jan Jelinek · Schaum100
Shy Layers · Shy Layers100
SongOther Votes
Demdike Stare · "FullEdge (eMpTy-40 Mix)"0
Georgia · "Ama Yes Uzume"0
Jeff Parker · "Slight Freedom"0
Lowtec · "Untitled A2"0
Motion Graphics · "Brass Mechanics"0
Roman Flügel · "Life Tends to Come and Go"0
Steve Hauschildt · "A False Seeming"0
Studio OST · "Itcz"0
Suzanne Kraft · "What You Get for Being Young"0
Visible Cloaks · "Terrazo (Feat. Motion Graphics)"0

Similar Ballots
.1506Mallory O'Donnell · 2016
.1426Lindsey Rhoades · 2016
.0956Jim Macnie · 2016
.0936Robert Loerzel · 2016
.0904Troy Farah · 2016
.0705Zach Kelly · 2016
.0694Christopher Matthew Jensen · 2016
.0664Jem Aswad · 2016
.0664Richard Gehr · 2016
.0654Jeremiah McNeil · 2016
.0654Rachel Leibrock · 2016
.0644Stephen Slaybaugh · 2016
.0634John Dugan · 2016
.0634Laurence Station · 2016
.0634Matt Sebastian · 2016
.0594Paula Mejia · 2016
.0584Scott Plagenhoef · 2016
.0544Mark Pytlik · 2016
.0524Todd Olmstead · 2016
.0464Bob Townsend · 2016
.0464Daniel Kreps · 2016
.0464Ed Masley · 2016
.0464Erik Thompson · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.117#395 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Kurt Vile · B'lieve I'm Goin Down1028
Julia Holter · Have You in My Wilderness1023
Oneohtrix Point Never · Garden of Delete1023
Arca · Mutant1012
Jim O'Rourke · Simple Songs1011
Zs · Xe104
Elysia Crampton · American Drift102
Deradoorian · The Expanding Flower Planet101
Filipe Felizardo · Volume IV - the Invading Past and Other Dissolutions100
Raphael Roginski · Plays John Coltrane and Langston Hughes African Mystic Music100
SongOther Votes
Kendrick Lamar · "Alright"65
Kurt Vile · "Pretty Pimpin"27
Beach House · "Sparks"9
DJ Koze · "Xtc"4
Julia Holter · "Feel You"4
Oneohtrix Point Never · "Sticky Drama"4
Deradoorian · "A Beautiful Woman"1
Jim O'Rourke · "Friends With Benefits"1
DJ Richard · "Savage Coast"0
Domenique Dumont · "L'Esprit de L'Escalier"0

Similar Ballots
.1799Scott Plagenhoef · 2015
.1668Jordan Cronk · 2015
.1558Mark Richardson · 2015
.1508Adam Kivel · 2015
.1044Andy Battaglia · 2015
.1036Kevin Korber · 2015
.1006Alex Woodward · 2015
.1006Brandon Stosuy · 2015
.0934Heather Phares · 2015
.0925Joseph Davenport · 2015
.0916Gabe Vodicka · 2015
.0916Jason P. Woodbury · 2015
.0775Marvin Lin · 2015
.0775Sama'an Ashrawi · 2015
.0755Reiff, Corbin Reiff · 2015
.0734Brandon Bussolini · 2015
.0725Michael Azerrad · 2015
.0715Kory Grow · 2015
.0695Colin St. John · 2015
.0685Christopher R. Weingarten · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.347#243 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
D'Angelo · Black Messiah10162
FKA Twigs · Lp11085
Grouper · Ruins1024
Owen Pallett · In Conflict1019
Andy Stott · Faith in Strangers1014
Arca · Xen108
Theo Parrish · American Intelligence106
PC Music · PC X Disown Radio Ft. A.G. Cook, GFOTY, Danny L Harle, Lil Data, Nu New Edition, and Kane West105
Jo Johnson · Weaving103
Rebolledo · Momento Drive100
SongOther Votes
D'Angelo · "Sugah Daddy"10
Sophie · "Lemonade"9
FKA Twigs · "Pendulum"6
Panda Bear · "Mr Noah"6
Grouper · "Holding"2
How to Dress Well · "Repeat Pleasure (A. G. Cook Remix)"1
Theo Parrish · "Be in Yo Self and Dance"1
Gabi · "Koo Koo"0
Institute · "An Absence"0
Rebolledo · "Windsurf, Sunburn and Dollar (Extended Raw Version)"0

Similar Ballots
.1908Joseph Davenport · 2014
.1546Cameron Macdonald · 2014
.1536Andy Battaglia · 2014
.1306Sean Michaels · 2014
.1217Alexis Stephens · 2014
.1156Stephen Bush · 2014
.1086Sasha Geffen · 2014
.1066Brandon Stosuy · 2014
.1066Daniel Sargeant · 2014
.1046Kyle Kramer · 2014
.1036Matthew Perpetua · 2014
.1026Aaron Frank · 2014
.1026Calum Marsh · 2014
.0986Dorian Lynskey · 2014
.0976John Seroff · 2014
.0966Randall Roberts · 2014
.0956Andy Beta · 2014
.0936Miles Raymer · 2014
.0914Kimberly Chun · 2014
.0895Fred Pessaro · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.292#237 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Maxmillion Dunbar · House of Woo300
James Holden · The Inheritors206
Kelela · Cut 4 Me1511
Haim · Days Are Gone561
Kurt Vile · Wakin on a Pretty Daze545
Queens of the Stone Age · ...Like Clockwork532
Tim Hecker · Virgins526
Julia Holter · Loud City Song510
DJ Rashad · Double Cup58
Death Grips · Government Plates54
SongOther Votes
Sophie · "Bipp"8
Kingdom (ft. Kelela) · "Bank Head"7
Todd Terje · "Strandbar (Disko)"6
Amir Alexander · "Don't Go"0
DJ Nigga Fox · "O Badaah"0
Galcher Lustwerk · "Put On"0
Jordan GCZ · "Crybaby J"0
Jtc · "Valley Road (We Are 1)"0
Marcus Marr · "The Music"0
Seven Davis Jr. · "One"0

Similar Ballots
.21810Ryan Schreiber · 2013
.1626Michael Deeds · 2013
.1538James Blount · 2013
.1176Rollie Pemberton · 2013
.1155Aaron Hillis · 2013
.1106Alan Baban · 2013
.1096Chris Randle · 2013
.1066D. Patrick Rodgers · 2013
.0974Jason Gargano · 2013
.0954Cameron Macdonald · 2013
.0934Nathaniel Hawks · 2013
.0885Pierre Lestruhaut · 2013
.0874Zeth Lundy · 2013
.0854Andy Battaglia · 2013
.0854Etan Rosenbloom · 2013
.0825Saul Austerlitz · 2013
.0805Rob Michaels · 2013
.0795Elliott Sharp · 2013
.0775Steven Hyden · 2013
.0694Calum Marsh · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.297#222 of 485
Metalism.050#70 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Kendrick Lamar · Good Kid, m.A.A.d City10125
Swans · The Seer1050
Pallbearer · Sorrow and Extinction1013
Actress · R.I.P.1012
Robert Glasper Experiment · Black Radio1012
Frankie Rose · Interstellar105
Daphni · Jiaolong103
Juju & Jordash · Techno Primitivism103
I:Cube · "M" Megamix102
Lee Gamble · Dutch Tvashtar Plumes100
SongOther Votes
Andrés · "New for You"4
Blawan · "Why They Hide Their Bodies Under My Garage?"2
Joy Orbison · "Ellipsis"2
I:Cube · "Transpiration"1
Elgato · "Zone"0
Makam · "What Ya Doin"0
Omar S · "S.E.X. (C.G.P (Conant Gardens Posse) Remix)"0
Pearson Sound · "Footloose"0
Ra.H & Dynamo Dreesn · "Space Pops (Donato Dozzy Remix)"0
Wk7 · "Do It Yourself"0

Similar Ballots
.1116James Blount · 2012
.1076Brandon Bussolini · 2012
.0906Brandon Stosuy · 2012
.0886Jessica Suarez · 2012
.0876Scott Plagenhoef · 2012
.0634Michaelangelo Matos · 2012
.0633Cameron Macdonald · 2012
.0614Anthony Miccio · 2012
.0614Dev Sherlock · 2012
.0604Ben Donnelly · 2012
.0604Brent Baldwin · 2012
.0594Michael Barthel · 2012
.0574Jordan Cronk · 2012
.0564Barry Bruner · 2012
.0464Eugene Holley, Jr. · 2012
.0464Ken Capobianco · 2012
.0464Trent Fitzgerald · 2012
.0444Daniel Kreps · 2012
.0444Del Cowie · 2012
.0444Rob Tannenbaum · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.170#506 of 693
Metalism.050#88 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Bon Iver · Bon Iver1079
Oneohtrix Point Never · Replica1034
Zola Jesus · Conatus1015
SBTRKT · SBTRKT109
Craig Taborn · Avenging Angel106
Little Dragon · Ritual Union105
Blut Aus Nord · 777: Sect(s)/The Desanctification104
Laurel Halo · Hour Logic101
Ricardo Donoso · Progress Chance100
Steve Hauschildt · Tragedy & Geometry100
SongOther Votes
Todd Terje · "Snooze 4 Love"7
Jacques Greene · "Another Girl"6
Mosca · "Bax"1
SBTRKT · "Right Thing to Do"1
Virgo Four · "It's a Crime (Caribou Remix)"1
Daphni · "Ye Ye"0
Joe Goddard · "Gabriel"0
Junior Boys · "You'll Improve Me (Caribou Remix)"0
Mario & Vidis · "Changed (John Talabot's Private Mix)"0
Rustie · "Ultra Thizz"0

Similar Ballots
.1377Scott Plagenhoef · 2011
.1086Mark Pytlik · 2011
.0934Brandon Stosuy · 2011
.0925Larry Fitzmaurice · 2011
.0845Andy Beta · 2011
.0844David Downs · 2011
.0815Erik Kenward · 2011
.0755Matthew Horton · 2011
.0644Puja Patel · 2011
.0614Nick Neyland · 2011
.0604Patrick McNally · 2011
.0604Vijith Assar · 2011
.0584Devon Maloney · 2011
.0544Amrit Singh · 2011
.0544Andrew Gaerig · 2011
.0544David Raposa · 2011
.0524Jeremy D. Larson · 2011
.0524Mike Powell · 2011
.0514Mark Richardson · 2011
.0484Brandon Soderberg · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.455#190 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Kanye West · My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy10265
LCD Soundsystem · This Is Happening10151
Robyn · Body Talk1073
Caribou · Swim1035
Emeralds · Does It Look Like I'm Here?1019
Oneohtrix Point Never · Returnal1018
Actress · Splazsh1013
Glasser · Ring1012
Teebs · Ardour104
Demdike Stare · Voices of Dust100
SongOther Votes
Robyn · "Dancing on My Own"79
Kanye West (ft. Jay-Z, Rick Ross, Nicki Minaj and Bon Iver) · "Monster"66
LCD Soundsystem · "I Can Change"36
James Blake · "Limit to Your Love"5
Oneohtrix Point Never · "Returnal"4
Glasser · "Apply"1
Gonzales · "I Am Europe"0
Jacob Korn · "Mirrorflip"0
Roman Flügel · "How to Spread Lies"0
Totally Enormous Extinct Dinosaurs · "Garden"0

Similar Ballots
.24312Jessica Suarez · 2010
.23612Scott Plagenhoef · 2010
.20111Rebecca Raber · 2010
.18010Matt Diehl · 2010
.17710Joe Colly · 2010
.17710Stacey Anderson · 2010
.1779Amy Granzin · 2010
.1739Jim Fouratt · 2010
.1676Ron Mashate · 2010
.1618Matthew Perpetua · 2010
.1579Dan Gibson · 2010
.1539Sal Cinquemani · 2010
.1519Chris Molanphy · 2010
.1489Amanda Petrusich · 2010
.1328Ken Rayes · 2010
.1308Althea Legaspi · 2010
.1258Joey Daniewicz · 2010
.1258Spencer Kornhaber · 2010
.1228Marissa G. Muller · 2010
.1218Puja Patel · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.133#498 of 683
Metalism.050#107 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
The xx · The xx1092
Sunn O))) · Monoliths and Dimensions1024
Emeralds · What Happened107
Black to Comm · Alphabet 1968103
Demdike Stare · Symbiosis101
Kevin Drumm · Imperial Horizon101
Benzo · The Dust/The Tapes: Mania Remixes100
Lukid · Foma100
Monolake · Silence100
Pepe Bradock · Confiote de Bits100
SongOther Votes
Joy Orbison · "Hyph Mngo"21
Andy Stott · "Drippin"0
Aufgang · "Channel 7 (You and Me Remix by John Talabot)"0
EQD · "EQD #003 B1"0
FaltyDL · "Metacognist"0
Jacques Palminger · "Tüdeldub (Shackleton Remix)"0
Oni Ayhun · "Oar003-A"0
Precious System · "The Voice From Planet Love"0
T++ · "Test#10Seed_Bit"0
Tortoise · "Gigantes - Mark Ernestus Version"0

Similar Ballots
.1076Joe Colly · 2009
.0834Geeta Dayal · 2009
.0664Joseph Davenport · 2009
.0644Christopher R. Weingarten · 2009
.0634Marc Gilman · 2009
.0604Chet Betz · 2009
.0594Aaron Hillis · 2009
.0584Jonathan Lundeen · 2009
.0584Scott Plagenhoef · 2009
.0574Mark Richardson · 2009
.0564Andrew Gaerig · 2009
.0564Will Hermes · 2009
.0544Gareth Grundy · 2009
.0544Mike Rubin · 2009
.0383Dave Segal · 2009
.0383Timothy Gabriele · 2009
.0363Justin Farrar · 2010
.0363Ken Taylor · 2009
.0343Stephen Bush · 2012
.0313Kory Grow · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.028#546 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Juana Molina · Un Dia1010
Osborne · Osborne102
Kieran Hebden & Steve Reid · NYC101
Newworldaquarium · The Dead Bears101
Thomas Brinkmann · When Horses Die101
Hatchback · Colors of the Sun100
Jasmina Maschina · The Demolition Series100
Lucky Dragons · Dream Island Laughing Language100
Ricardo Villalobos · Vasco100
(various artists) · Soundboy's Gravestone Gets Desecrated by Vandals100
SongOther Votes
Invisible Conga People · "Cable Dazed"6
Move D · "Drøne"1
tobias. · "I Can't Fight the Feeling"1
DJ Koze · "I Want to Sleep"0
Los Updates · "Pictures of You (Tobias. Remix)"0
Play Doe · "Joker & Rustie"0
Ricardo Villalobos · "Minimoonstar"0
Rustie · "Zig-Zag"0
Scuba · "Twitch (Jamie Vex'd Remix)"0
Zomby · "The Lie"0

Similar Ballots
.0644Andy Kellman · 2008
.0614Todd Burns · 2008
.0282Jay Lustig · 2008
.0282Steve Ciabattoni · 2008
.0272Andy Battaglia · 2013
.0272Kembrew McLeod · 2008
.0262Jon Young · 2008
.0262Michael Ross · 2008
.0262Nathaniel Hawks · 2009
.0262Steve Hochman · 2008
.0192Brian Howe · 2008
.0192Mike Orme · 2008
.0192Nate Cavalieri · 2008
.0183Andy Beta · 2008
.0182Andrew Gaerig · 2008
.0182Chris Toenes · 2008
.0182Michael Azerrad · 2008
.0182Nick Sylvester · 2008
.0182Otis Hart · 2008
.0182Scott Plagenhoef · 2008
Similar Voters
.12346Scott Plagenhoef
.11526James Blount
.11430Jordan Cronk
.10331Joseph Davenport
.10128Andy Battaglia
.09922Cameron Macdonald
.09030Brandon Bussolini
.08626Daniel Sargeant
.08328Mark Richardson
.07926Aaron Hillis
.07925Stephen Bush
.07921Joe Colly
.07830Rob Michaels
.07823Brandon Stosuy
.07725Andrew Gaerig
.07719Ryan Schreiber
.07618Jessica Suarez
.07515Sam Hockley-Smith
.07425Erik Kenward
.07421Dominique Leone
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com