This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Jim Testa
Overall
Centricity.154#1030 of 1313
Breadth.478#404 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.088#449 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Drive-By Truckers · American Band1055
Savages · Adore Life1021
Cymbals Eat Guitars · Pretty Years1012
Bob Mould · Patch the Sky109
Eleanor Friedberger · New View102
The Gotobeds · Blood//Sugar//Secs//Traffic101
Kevin Devine · Instigator100
Pansy Division · Quite Contrary100
Peter Stampfel · Holiday for Strings100
Richard Barone · Sorrows & Promises: Greenwich Village in the 1960's100

Similar Ballots
.2006Jim DeRogatis · 2016
.1134Steve Klinge · 2016
.1094Mark Deming · 2016
.0734John Everhart · 2016
.0724L. Kent Wolgamott · 2016
.0694David Goldstein · 2016
.0684Travis Hay · 2016
.0674Jim Tremayne · 2016
.0503Zach Schonfeld · 2016
.0453Jim Testa · 2011
.0413Matt Fiander · 2016
.0403Daniel Durchholz · 2016
.0393Fred Mills · 2016
.0373Dorian Lynskey · 2016
.0332Mike Rowell · 2016
.0322Ian Cohen · 2016
.0312Jeanne Fury · 2016
.0312Stephen Slaybaugh · 2016
.0302Matt Sebastian · 2016
.0302Steve Horowitz · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.231#326 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Courtney Barnett · Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit10166
Beach Slang · The Things We Do to Find People Who Feel Like Us1015
Yo la Tengo · Stuff Like That There1011
Jeffrey Lewis & Los Bolts · Manhattan108
Screaming Females · Rose Mountain108
Pwr Bttm · Ugly Cherries103
Worriers · Imaginary Life102
Night Birds · Mutiny at Muscle Beach101
Front Bottoms · Back on Top100
Roadside Graves · Acne/Ears100

Similar Ballots
.2046Robert Christgau · 2015
.1906Dan Strachota · 2015
.1778Nick Spacek · 2015
.1044James Bradley · 2015
.1024Brian Orloff · 2015
.1014Nicholas Taylor · 2015
.1004Cam Patterson · 2015
.1004Jim DeRogatis · 2015
.1004Michael Tatum · 2015
.0693Jim Testa · 2009
.0664Mike Appelstein · 2015
.0644Andrew Unterberger · 2015
.0644Isa Jones · 2015
.0634Jessica Goodman · 2015
.0624Brian J. Peterson · 2015
.0624Caryn Rose · 2015
.0624Jon LaFollette · 2015
.0624Phillip Overeem · 2015
.0624Ted Cox · 2015
.0614Daniel Kohn · 2015
.0614Michael Pollock · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.154#446 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Lana Del Rey · Ultraviolence1044
tUnE-yArDs · Nikki Nack1031
Real Estate · Atlas1022
Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers · Hypnotic Eye1012
Weezer · Everything Will Be Alright in the End1011
Cymbals Eat Guitars · Lose1010
The Gotobeds · Poor People Are Revolting103
Loudon Wainwright III · Haven't Got the Blues (Yet)103
Conor Oberst · Upside Down Mountain102
Karen Haglof · Western Holiday100
SongOther Votes
Taylor Swift · "Shake It Off"52
tUnE-yArDs · "Water Fountain"25
War on Drugs · "Red Eyes"25
Against Me! · "Transgender Dysphoria Blues"12
Real Estate · "Talking Backwards"9
Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers · "Fault Lines"2
Cymbals Eat Guitars · "Jackson"1
Shellac · "Dude, Incredible"1
Jeffrey Lewis · "What Would Pussy Riot Do"0
Loudon Wainwright III · "Brand New Dance"0

Similar Ballots
.20410Dan Caffrey · 2014
.1476David Goldstein · 2014
.1305Michael Ayers · 2014
.1267E.J. Friedman · 2014
.1185Salvatore Caputo · 2014
.1146Erik Sateren · 2014
.1014John Everhart · 2014
.1006Matthew Oshinsky · 2014
.0986Gabriel Rosenberg · 2014
.0966Douglas Wolk · 2014
.0966Ed Condran · 2014
.0956Jonathan Lundeen · 2014
.0954Jim DeRogatis · 2014
.0944Jack Buehrer · 2014
.0926Maria Jean Sullivan · 2014
.0916Kory Grow · 2014
.0906Dan DeLuca · 2014
.0875Adam Kivel · 2014
.0855Michael Roffman · 2014
.0845Ben Salmon · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.415#163 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Vampire Weekend · Modern Vampires of the City10108
Chance the Rapper · Acid Rap1062
Savages · Silence Yourself1041
Parquet Courts · Light Up Gold1028
Earl Sweatshirt · Doris1020
Superchunk · I Hate Music1019
Dismemberment Plan · Uncanney Valley106
Front Bottoms · Talon of the Hawk104
Jeffrey Lewis & Peter Stampfel Band · Hey Hey It's...the Jeffrey Lewis & Peter Stampfel Band103
Kevin Devine & the Goddamn Band · Bubblegum100
SongOther Votes
Daft Punk (ft. Pharrell Williams) · "Get Lucky"116
Superchunk · "Me & You & Jackie Mittoo"14
Vampire Weekend · "Hannah Hunt"11
Pet Shop Boys · "Love Is a Bourgeois Construct"6
One Direction · "Best Song Ever"4
Chance the Rapper · "Cocoa Butter Kisses"3
Dismemberment Plan · "Daddy Was a Real Good Dancer"1
Earl Sweatshirt · "Burgundy"1
Parquet Courts · "Master of My Craft"1
Speedy Ortiz · "Taylor Swift"1

Similar Ballots
.2448Todd Martens · 2013
.21911Lindsey Thomas · 2013
.21210Joey Hood · 2013
.19310Greg Kot · 2013
.18810Harry Burson · 2013
.18510Christopher Monsen · 2013
.1736Jason Gargano · 2013
.1689Christian Hoard · 2013
.1686Josh Modell · 2013
.1679Jonah LaFollette · 2013
.1616Jim DeRogatis · 2013
.1458Dan DeLuca · 2013
.1448Gary Chun · 2013
.1338Steve Kiviat · 2013
.1237L. Kent Wolgamott · 2013
.1217Chris Molanphy · 2013
.1217Eric Danton · 2013
.1217Steve Reynolds · 2013
.1207Dorian Lynskey · 2013
.1187Sean Fennessey · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.122#368 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Bob Dylan · Tempest1032
Loudon Wainwright III · Older Than My Old Man Now1015
Bob Mould · Silver Age1014
Redd Kross · Researching the Blues109
The dB's · Falling Off the Sky108
Screaming Females · Ugly106
Craig Finn · Clear Heart, Full Eyes103
Bad Books · Ii100
Big Dipper · Crashes on the Platinium Planet100
Tim Fite · Ain't Ain't Ain't100
SongOther Votes
Carly Rae Jepsen · "Call Me Maybe"93
Japandroids · "The House That Heaven Built"46
Taylor Swift · "We Are Never Ever Getting Back Together"42
Frank Ocean · "Bad Religion"15
Bob Dylan · "Duquesne Whistle"10
One Direction · "What Makes You Beautiful"3
Bad Books · "Forest Whitaker"0
Big Dipper · "Robert Pollard"0
Bob Mould · "Star Machine"0
Soul Asylum · "Gravity"0

Similar Ballots
.2057Stephen Haag · 2012
.1649Joey Daniewicz · 2012
.1406Jim Farber · 2012
.1197Mike Madden · 2012
.1137Christopher Monsen · 2012
.1115Peter Gerstenzang · 2012
.1106Rembert Browne · 2012
.1087Michael Gallucci · 2012
.1077Brian Orloff · 2012
.1066Max Berry · 2012
.1047Glenn Gamboa · 2012
.1047Rebecca Raber · 2012
.1037Scott Lapatine · 2012
.1017Jon Bream · 2012
.1017Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2012
.0994Evie Nagy · 2012
.0955Franklin Soults · 2012
.0924Bob Townsend · 2012
.0916Michael Tatum · 2012
.0916Rob Sheffield · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.147#527 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Paul Simon · So Beautiful or So What1060
Real Estate · Days1039
Eleanor Friedberger · Last Summer1014
Feelies · Here Before1013
Cymbals Eat Guitars · Lenses Alien103
Smithereens · 2011102
Jeffrey Lewis · A Turn in the Dream-Songs101
House Boat · The Thorns of Life100
Kevin Devine · Between the Concrete and Clouds100
Roadside Graves · We Can Take Care of Ourselves100
SongOther Votes
Wild Flag · "Romance"31
Lady Gaga · "Born This Way"19
Smith Westerns · "Weekend"8
Paul Simon · "Getting Ready for Christmas Day"6
Real Estate · "Green Aisles"6
Front Bottoms · "Maps"1
Cage the Elephant · "2024"0
Cymbals Eat Guitars · "Gary Condit"0
Jeffrey Lewis · "Alternative Boyfriend"0
Nat & Alex Wolff · "Thump Thump Thump"0

Similar Ballots
.0994Jason Cherkis · 2011
.0964Jeff Tamarkin · 2011
.0925Ted Cox · 2011
.0885Britt Robson · 2011
.0875Ken Rayes · 2011
.0835Jenn Pelly · 2011
.0825Michael Ayers · 2011
.0825Rebecca Raber · 2011
.0805Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2011
.0694Anna Deem · 2011
.0654Heidi Vanderlee · 2011
.0644Carter Maness · 2011
.0644Paul Thompson · 2011
.0634David Greenwald · 2011
.0624Matt Sebastian · 2011
.0624Sarah Ventre · 2011
.0624Scott Mervis · 2011
.0614Wesley Case · 2011
.0604Anthony Easton · 2011
.0604Chris Richards · 2011
.0604Derek Paiva · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.069#595 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Superchunk · Majesty Shredding1048
Ted Leo and the Pharmacists · The Brutalist Bricks1015
Hold Steady · Heaven Is Whenever1012
Screaming Females · Castle Talk105
Bad Religion · The Dissent of Man102
April Smith & the Great Picture Show · Songs for a Sinking Ship101
The Dopamines · Expect the Worst100
River City Extension · The Unmistakable Man100
Riverdales · Tarantula100
Roadside Graves · You Won't Be Happy With Me100

Similar Ballots
.2036Matt Hickey · 2010
.1504Jed Gottlieb · 2010
.1144Jason Buhrmester · 2010
.1134David Peisner · 2010
.1094Matthew Fritch · 2010
.1065Patrick Rapa · 2010
.0935Joe Gross · 2010
.0764Jeanne Fury · 2010
.0734Evie Nagy · 2010
.0733Jim Testa · 2009
.0714Michael Tedder · 2010
.0674Kory Grow · 2010
.0423Drew Fortune · 2010
.0413Doug Wallen · 2010
.0403Michael Mannheimer · 2010
.0393Steve Reynolds · 2010
.0352Jason Simms · 2010
.0352Martin Cizmar · 2010
.0342J Poet · 2010
.0342Sean Nelson · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.049#616 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Jeffrey Lewis & the Junkyard · 'Em Are I201
Yo la Tengo · Popular Songs1024
Screaming Females · Power Move1010
Cymbals Eat Guitars · Why There Are Mountains105
Roadside Graves · My Son's Home101
Ace Enders & a Million Different People · When I Hit the Ground100
Ike Reilly · Hard Luck Stories100
Riverdales · Invasion USA100
Golden Bloom · Fan the Flames50
The Leftovers · Eager to Please50

Similar Ballots
.0743Jim Testa · 2010
.0734John Everhart · 2009
.0724Matthew Oshinsky · 2009
.0703Jim Testa · 2015
.0453Justin Gage · 2009
.0342Jim DeRogatis · 2009
.0342Lindsay Zoladz · 2009
.0342Tobias Carroll · 2009
.0332MacKenzie Wilson · 2009
.0322Luke Hackney · 2009
.0312Jim Sullivan · 2009
.0292Curtis Schieber · 2009
.0292Dan Aloi · 2009
.0292Deborah Sprague · 2009
.0292Drew Fortune · 2009
.0292Jonah Bayer · 2009
.0292Rich Bienstock · 2009
.0212Arsenio Orteza · 2009
.0212Joe Stumble · 2009
.0212Michael Krugman · 2009
.0212Nick Spacek · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.109#452 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Hold Steady · Stay Positive1053
Los Campesinos! · Hold on Now, Youngster...1031
McCarthy Trenching · Calamity Drenching101
The Campbell Apartment · Insomniac's Almanac100
The Guts · Let It Go100
The Measure (SA) · Songs About People...And Fruit N Shit100
Peachcake · What Year Will You Have the World?100
Spiraling · Time Travel Made Easy100
The Steinways · Gorilla Marketing100
Val Emmich · Little Hammers100

Similar Ballots
.1124Michael Deeds · 2008
.0894Rickey Wright · 2008
.0704Lindsey Thomas · 2008
.0704William Bowers · 2008
.0674Chris Herrington · 2008
.0654Whitney Pastorek · 2008
.0644Greg Beets · 2008
.0423Stephen Haag · 2008
.0403Ryan Dombal · 2008
.0312Marc Hogan · 2008
.0312Max Berry · 2008
.0302Grant Moser · 2008
.0292Liz Riley · 2008
.0282Andrew Bartlett · 2008
.0282Britt Robson · 2008
.0282Cortney Harding · 2008
.0272Jay Lustig · 2008
.0272Julie Seabaugh · 2008
.0272Kevin Pearson · 2008
.0272Meredith Ochs · 2008
Similar Voters
.14726Jim DeRogatis
.11019Dan Caffrey
.09626Michael Tatum
.08913Evie Nagy
.08724Lindsey Thomas
.08531L. Kent Wolgamott
.08421Max Berry
.08020Greg Kot
.08013Jonah LaFollette
.07918Stephen Haag
.07825Robert Christgau
.07715Harry Burson
.07626Michael Gallucci
.07421Dan DeLuca
.07421Travis Hay
.07416Michael Tedder
.07223Joey Daniewicz
.07212Franklin Soults
.07122Christopher Monsen
.07119Dorian Lynskey
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com