This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Brian Orloff
Overall
Centricity.517#220 of 1313
Breadth.711#117 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.286#329 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Solange · A Seat at the Table10116
Angel Olsen · My Woman1070
Mitski · Puberty 21058
Anohni · Hopelessness1037
Whitney · Light Upon the Lake1018
Jamila Woods · Heavn1016
PJ Harvey · The Hope Six Demolition Project1016
Lambchop · Flotus1015
Andrew Bird · Are You Serious100
Little Scream · Cult Following100

Similar Ballots
.2176Joshua Terry · 2016
.1996Jason Gargano · 2016
.1996Mallory O'Donnell · 2016
.1988Katie Moulton · 2016
.1928Ramon Ramirez · 2016
.1868Joe Lynch · 2016
.1858Marissa G. Muller · 2016
.1577Kasia Galazka · 2016
.1567Pat Levy · 2016
.1547Josh Timmermann · 2016
.1537Melissa Locker · 2016
.1446Jessica Gentile · 2016
.1386Erik Thompson · 2016
.1296Shannon Carlin · 2016
.1276Simon Vozick-Levinson · 2016
.1256Spencer Kornhaber · 2016
.1256Stephen Thompson · 2016
.1206Gabriel Rosenberg · 2016
.1206Jamieson Cox · 2016
.1206Will Hermes · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.670#43 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Kendrick Lamar · To Pimp a Butterfly10209
Courtney Barnett · Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit10166
Sufjan Stevens · Carrie & Lowell1081
Tame Impala · Currents1052
Miguel · Wildheart1049
Torres · Sprinter1026
Julia Holter · Have You in My Wilderness1023
Mbongwana Star · From Kinshasa1019
Yo la Tengo · Stuff Like That There1011
Benjamin Clementine · At Least for Now104

Similar Ballots
.2598Jim DeRogatis · 2015
.2418Jason Gargano · 2015
.2418Scott Mervis · 2015
.2176Janelle Bitker · 2015
.20710Shannon Carlin · 2015
.19810Hardeep Phull · 2015
.1986Steve Hochman · 2015
.1859Philip Cosores · 2015
.1829Todd Olmstead · 2015
.1819Seth Mnookin · 2015
.1809Christopher Barton · 2015
.1698Val Veteto · 2015
.1648Melissa Fossum · 2015
.1638Reed Fischer · 2015
.1606Preston Jones · 2015
.1588Michael Gallucci · 2015
.1578Roy Trakin · 2015
.1568Will Hermes · 2015
.1566Robert Christgau · 2015
.1546Laurence Station · 2015
.1546Michael Tatum · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.441#159 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Perfume Genius · Too Bright2035
St. Vincent · St. Vincent15111
War on Drugs · Lost in the Dream10103
Ex Hex · Rips1057
Jenny Lewis · The Voyager1037
Hurray for the Riff Raff · Small Town Heroes1012
Wye Oak · Shriek107
Beck · Morning Phase550
Meshell Ndegeocello · Comet, Come to Me56
Ginger Baker · Why?50
SongOther Votes
FKA Twigs · "Two Weeks"59
Taylor Swift · "Shake It Off"52
Sia · "Chandelier"39
Sam Smith · "Stay With Me"27
Sturgill Simpson · "Turtles All the Way Down"20
Sylvan Esso · "Coffee"12
Jessie Ware · "Tough Love"11
Beyoncé · "Xo"7
My Brightest Diamond · "Pressure"1
Sharon Van Etten · "Taking Chances"0

Similar Ballots
.3009Janelle Bitker · 2014
.25912Michelle Geslani · 2014
.25412Andrew Dansby · 2014
.25012Katie Moulton · 2014
.24912Stephen M. Deusner · 2014
.24713Jim Fouratt · 2014
.23512Shannon Carlin · 2014
.23112Dan Kois · 2014
.21811Erik Thompson · 2014
.21811Kyle Petersen · 2014
.21311Andrea Domanick · 2014
.21311Rob Harvilla · 2014
.21211Joey Hood · 2014
.20511Mac Wilson · 2014
.2027Steve Horowitz · 2014
.19811Maud Deitch · 2014
.19310Adam Gold · 2014
.19211Jennifer Vineyard · 2014
.1929Amy McCarthy · 2014
.1847Michael Ayers · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.399#169 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Vampire Weekend · Modern Vampires of the City10108
Kurt Vile · Wakin on a Pretty Daze1045
Arcade Fire · Reflektor1042
Laura Marling · Once I Was an Eagle1021
Rhye · Woman1018
Bill Callahan · Dream River1017
Phosphorescent · Muchacho1017
Valerie June · Pushin' Against a Stone1010
Concha Buika · La Noche Mas Larga102
Trixie Whitley · Fourth Corner101
SongOther Votes
Kanye West · "New Slaves"40
Kacey Musgraves · "Follow Your Arrow"21
Katy Perry · "Roar"12
Chvrches · "Recover"10
Sky Ferreira · "You're Not the One"9
Janelle Monáe (ft. Miguel) · "Primetime"7
Lorde · "Tennis Court"2
Neko Case · "Night Still Comes"2
Camera Obscura · "Do It Again"0
Sam Amidon · "My Old Friend"0

Similar Ballots
.2539Allen St John · 2013
.20611Phil Gallo · 2013
.20011Mac Wilson · 2013
.19310Stephen Thompson · 2013
.1928Scott Mervis · 2013
.1897Steve Klinge · 2013
.1838Jeff Vrabel · 2013
.1779Saul Austerlitz · 2013
.1739John Vettese · 2013
.1707Nicholas Taylor · 2013
.1679Rodney Carmichael · 2013
.1589Forrest Wickman · 2013
.1559Joey Hood · 2013
.1519Jamieson Cox · 2013
.1429Jeff Gage · 2013
.1428Michael Gallucci · 2013
.1419Andrew Dansby · 2013
.1408Althea Legaspi · 2013
.1408Caitlin White · 2013
.1378Erik Thompson · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.421#141 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Frank Ocean · Channel Orange10169
Bob Dylan · Tempest1032
Cat Power · Sun1031
Grizzly Bear · Shields1029
Jessie Ware · Devotion1022
Purity Ring · Shrines1019
Kelly Hogan · I Like to Keep Myself in Pain1014
Getatchew Mekuria & the Ex & Friends · Y'Anbessaw Tezeta102
Meshell Ndegeocello · Pour Une Ame Souveraine102
Sera Cahoone · Deer Creek Canyon102
SongOther Votes
Carly Rae Jepsen · "Call Me Maybe"93
Miguel · "Adorn"55
Frank Ocean · "Thinkin' 'Bout You"46
Japandroids · "The House That Heaven Built"46
Solange · "Losing You"40
Fiona Apple · "Anything We Want"2
Yeasayer · "Longevity"2
Beach House · "Lazuli"1
Dirty Projectors · "About to Die"1
Poliça · "Lay Your Cards Out"1

Similar Ballots
.23011Erin Thompson · 2012
.22912Althea Legaspi · 2012
.21911Lindsay Zoladz · 2012
.21511Katherine St. Asaph · 2012
.21111Joey Daniewicz · 2012
.20511Josh Bis · 2012
.20110Caitlin White · 2012
.19910Jeff Gage · 2012
.19711Chris Molanphy · 2012
.19110Tyler Coates · 2012
.18610Michael Gallucci · 2012
.18410Scott Lapatine · 2012
.1829Ramit Singh · 2012
.18010Carter Maness · 2012
.1759Todd Olmstead · 2012
.17310Will Hermes · 2012
.17110Jillian Mapes · 2012
.1719Rembert Browne · 2012
.1658Luis Paez-Pumar · 2012
.1639Amanda Petrusich · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.583#44 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
tUnE-yArDs · w h o k i l l10134
Wild Flag · Wild Flag1090
Destroyer · Kaputt1078
The Weeknd · House of Balloons1062
The Roots · Undun1059
Kurt Vile · Smoke Ring for My Halo1055
Wye Oak · Civilian1027
Colin Stetson · New History Warfare Vol. 2: Judges1021
Laura Marling · A Creature I Don't Know1012
Jessica Lea Mayfield · Tell Me108
SongOther Votes
Adele · "Rolling in the Deep"109
Cass McCombs · "County Line"24
PJ Harvey · "The Words That Maketh Murder"15
St. Vincent · "Cruel"14
Lykke Li · "Get Some"13
Wilco · "I Might"12
James Blake · "The Wilhelm Scream"11
Fleet Foxes · "Helplessness Blues"10
Frank Ocean · "Swim Good"5
Wild Beasts · "Albatross"1

Similar Ballots
.2679Ben Sisario · 2011
.26614Steve Erickson · 2011
.23512Carl Wilson · 2011
.23512Steve Klinge · 2011
.22911Eric Harvey · 2011
.22312Michael Ayers · 2011
.22011Dan Kois · 2011
.21211Tim Grierson · 2011
.20510Sean Michaels · 2011
.2038Paul Robicheau · 2011
.20210Althea Legaspi · 2011
.19710Simon Vozick-Levinson · 2011
.19210Tyler Coates · 2011
.19110Jason Diamond · 2011
.19110Marissa G. Muller · 2011
.19110Rebecca Raber · 2011
.1899Joel Elliott · 2011
.1879Laura Leebove · 2011
.18410Monica Herrera · 2011
.18310Chandler Levack · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.575#88 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Kanye West · My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy10265
Arcade Fire · The Suburbs10144
Janelle Monáe · The ArchAndroid10133
Beach House · Teen Dream10110
Best Coast · Crazy for You1043
Sharon Van Etten · Epic1022
Warpaint · The Fool1011
Wild Nothing · Gemini1011
Sam Amidon · I See the Sign106
Robert Wyatt, Gilad Atzmon, Ros Stephen · For the Ghosts Within103
SongOther Votes
Cee Lo Green · "Fuck You!"186
Robyn · "Dancing on My Own"79
The National · "Bloodbuzz Ohio"40
Erykah Badu · "Window Seat"36
Lady Gaga (ft. Beyoncé) · "Telephone"26
B.o.B (ft. Bruno Mars) · "Nothin' on You"17
Yeasayer · "Ambling Alp"13
Lady Antebellum · "Need You Now"11
Jay-Z (ft. Alicia Keys) · "Empire State of Mind"2
Sufjan Stevens · "All Delighted People"1

Similar Ballots
.30616Eric Danton · 2010
.24614Tim Grierson · 2010
.24513James Montgomery · 2010
.24313Julia Simon · 2010
.24013Stacey Anderson · 2010
.23813Serene Dominic · 2010
.23513Chris Molanphy · 2010
.22511Amy Granzin · 2010
.2259Ben Sisario · 2010
.21711Michael Ayers · 2010
.21012Luke Hackney · 2010
.20312Jim Connelly · 2010
.20211Puja Patel · 2010
.20111Emily Tartanella · 2010
.19212Dan DeLuca · 2010
.18911Kenneth Partridge · 2010
.18511Amanda Petrusich · 2010
.1849Anna Deem · 2010
.18110Mark Pytlik · 2010
.1809Andy Odom · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.598#33 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
St. Vincent · Actor1561
Wild Beasts · Two Dancers158
Phoenix · Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix10138
Dirty Projectors · Bitte Orca10107
Grizzly Bear · Veckatimest10105
Neko Case · Middle Cyclone10105
Camera Obscura · My Maudlin Career1031
The Very Best · Warm Heart of Africa1017
Antony & the Johnsons · The Crying Light529
BLK JKS · After Robots57
SongOther Votes
Jay-Z (ft. Alicia Keys) · "Empire State of Mind"88
Girls · "Lust for Life"41
Taylor Swift · "You Belong With Me"39
Lady Gaga · "Paparazzi"35
Bat for Lashes · "Daniel"26
The Big Pink · "Dominos"19
The xx · "Crystalised"17
Ida Maria · "I Like You So Much Better When You're Naked"4
Metric · "Gimme Sympathy"4
Florence & the Machine · "Kiss With a Fist"3

Similar Ballots
.35717Jennifer Vineyard · 2009
.35516Julia Simon · 2009
.32415Caitlin Dewey · 2009
.30515Matthew Perpetua · 2009
.29515Paul Robicheau · 2009
.29410Laura Barcella · 2009
.28910Jose Davila · 2009
.2858Brooke Foster · 2009
.28113Michael Ayers · 2009
.25612Stephen M. Deusner · 2009
.25512Melissa Maerz · 2009
.2559Chris Parker · 2009
.2529Julie Seabaugh · 2009
.2519Joan Anderman · 2009
.25012Andy Greenwald · 2009
.24711Adriane Goetz · 2009
.23812Chris Molanphy · 2009
.23811Michael Endelman · 2009
.22712Eric Danton · 2009
.2268David Shirley · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.680#11 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
TV on the Radio · Dear Science10153
Portishead · Third10101
Fleet Foxes · Fleet Foxes1087
Erykah Badu · New Amerykah, Pt. 1: 4th World War1079
Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds · Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!!1060
Hercules and Love Affair · Hercules and Love Affair1041
David Byrne and Brian Eno · Everything That Happens Will Happen Today1027
She & Him · Volume One1027
Laura Marling · Alas I Cannot Swim109
Land of Talk · Some Are Lakes103
SongOther Votes
Beyoncé · "Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)"57
Lil Wayne · "A Milli"49
Santogold · "L.E.S. Artistes"48
T.I. · "Whatever You Like"20
Adele · "Chasing Pavements"19
Katy Perry · "I Kissed a Girl"14
Sigur Rós · "Gobbledigook"10
Amadou & Mariam · "Sabali"2
Britney Spears · "Circus"2
Brazilian Girls · "Good Time"0

Similar Ballots
.27513Preston Jones · 2008
.2589Dominic Salerno · 2008
.24813Eric Weisbard · 2008
.24613Rob Brunner · 2008
.2469Ken Micallef · 2008
.23612Paul Robicheau · 2008
.23112Greg Kot · 2008
.23011Michael Ayers · 2008
.22912Kristal Hawkins · 2008
.22712Theon Weber · 2008
.22110Todd Hutlock · 2008
.2168David Shirley · 2008
.2158Laurence Station · 2008
.21011Charles Aaron · 2008
.2088Ed Condran · 2008
.20410Julia Simon · 2008
.19810Mordechai Shinefield · 2008
.19611Melissa Maerz · 2008
.19410Kory Grow · 2008
.1928Bo Pogue · 2008
Similar Voters
.24769Michael Ayers
.22042Julia Simon
.21977Althea Legaspi
.21776Will Hermes
.21763Steve Klinge
.20062Scott Mervis
.19470Paul Robicheau
.19168Michael Gallucci
.19146Jason Gargano
.19068Stephen M. Deusner
.18471Chris Molanphy
.18365Jennifer Vineyard
.17952Amanda Petrusich
.17741Mac Wilson
.17548Dan Kois
.17266Eric Danton
.16938Laura Leebove
.16266Mark Zepezauer
.16233Shannon Carlin
.16162Jim Fouratt
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com