This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Bill Holmes
Overall
Centricity.041#1262 of 1313
Breadth.578#257 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.063#467 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Ian Hunter · Fingers Crossed120
Sulo · Brilliant Outsiders120
Drive-By Truckers · American Band1055
I Don't Cares · Wild Stab104
Bun E. Carlos · Greetings From Bunezuela!101
Butch Walker · Stay Gold101
Todd Snider · Eastside Bulldog101
Cotton Mather · Death of the Cool100
Nada Surf · You Know Who You Are86
Quireboys · Twisted Love80
SongOther Votes
Pretenders · "Holy Commotion"3
Butch Walker · "Stay Gold"1
Bun E. Carlos · "Tell Me"0
Cheap Trick · "Sing My Blues Away"0
Ian Hunter · "Dandy"0
Kurt Baker Combo · "Baby's Gone Bad"0
Nick Piunti · "One Hit Wonder"0
Rolling Stones · "Just Your Fool"0
Samm Henshaw · "Our Love"0
Weeklings · "Little Elvis"0

Similar Ballots
.1216Jim Connelly · 2016
.0954Bill Holdship · 2016
.0924Mark Deming · 2016
.0664Chris Herrington · 2016
.0634Steve Reynolds · 2016
.0543Charles R. Cross · 2016
.0543Larry King · 2016
.0533Michael Deeds · 2016
.0513Jim Bessman · 2016
.0413Annie Zaleski · 2016
.0413Chris M. Junior · 2016
.0393Charles Johnson · 2016
.0393L. Kent Wolgamott · 2016
.0373Michael Lach · 2016
.0373Rick Mitchell · 2016
.0363Brian Ives · 2016
.0353Holly Gleason · 2016
.0343Ted Cox · 2016
.0292Steve Horowitz · 2016
.0282Jeffrey Morgan · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.022#462 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Sonics · This Is the Sonics209
Low Cut Connie · Hi Honey153
Jesse Malin · Outsiders100
Kurt Baker · Play It Cool100
Michael Carpenter · The Big Radio100
Connection · Labor of Love70
Dan Baird and Homemade Sin · Get Loud70
Michael Monroe · Blackout States70
New Trocaderos · Thrills and Chills70
Ryan Hamilton · Hell of a Day70
SongOther Votes
Ryan Adams · "Bad Blood"1
Connection · "Don't Come Back"0
Cotton Mather · "The Book of Too Late Changes"0
Detroit Cobras · "Feel Good"0
Dictators NYC · "Supply and Demand"0
Motobunny · "Let's Go Out"0
Sonics · "Sugaree"0
Steve Deaton Three · "Peroxide Blonde in a Hopped Up Model Ford"0
Wifee and the Huzz Band · "She Won't Go"0
Wyldlife · "Rock Candy"0

Similar Ballots
.0644Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2015
.0603Steve Simels · 2015
.0292Jim DeRogatis · 2015
.0272Gillian Gaar · 2015
.0272Rob O'Connor · 2015
.0262Andrew Hamlin · 2015
.0192L. Kent Wolgamott · 2015
.0182Jeanne Fury · 2015
.0182M.J. Fine · 2015
.0172Amy Reitnouer · 2016
.0172Ben Westhoff · 2015
.0172Mark Deming · 2015
.0162Steve Reynolds · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.035#566 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
The Empty Hearts · The Empty Hearts143
Reigning Sound · Shattered116
Hard Working Americans · Hard Working Americans111
Lake Street Dive · Bad Self Portraits105
Mount Carmel · Get Pure100
Split Squad · Now Hear This100
Steve Conte · The NYC Album100
Wilko Johnson/Roger Daltrey · Going Back Home85
Rival Sons · Great Western Valkyrie83
Trigger Hippy · Trigger Hippy80

Similar Ballots
.1234Jeff Tamarkin · 2014
.0342Dave Gil de Rubio · 2014
.0342Jeffrey Morgan · 2014
.0342Matt Ryan · 2014
.0342Peter Gerstenzang · 2014
.0332Dan Ferguson · 2014
.0332Jim Bessman · 2014
.0332Stephen Haag · 2014
.0332Steve Simels · 2014
.0322Matthew Horne · 2014
.0272Bill Holdship · 2014
.0232Hilary Hughes · 2014
.0232Jud Cost · 2014
.0232Michael Lach · 2014
.0222John Walker · 2014
.0212Patrick Rogers · 2014
.0212Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2014
.0202Fred Pessaro · 2014
.0202Jim Farber · 2014
.0202Kira Grunenberg · 2014
.0202Mac Randall · 2014
.0202Matt Fiander · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.024#439 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Del Lords · Elvis Club103
Norah Jones and Billie Joe Armstrong · Foreverly102
Willie Nile · American Ride102
Houndmouth · From the Hills Below the City101
Connection · Let It Rock100
John Paul Keith · Memphis Circa 3AM100
Nick Piunti · 13 in My Head100
Smith Westerns · Soft Will100
Strypes · Snapshot100
Wyatt Funderburk · Modern and Profane100

Similar Ballots
.1234Peter Gerstenzang · 2013
.0332Jim Allen · 2011
.0312Jeff Tamarkin · 2013
.0262Larry King · 2013
.0262Mark Deming · 2013
.0232Jason MacNeil · 2013
.0222Bill Holdship · 2013
.0222L. Kent Wolgamott · 2014
.0212Dave Lindquist · 2013
.0202Chris M. Junior · 2014
.0202Jim Farber · 2014
.0202Tom Hull · 2014
2012 original ballot
Centricity.054#438 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Redd Kross · Researching the Blues129
Black Keys · El Camino121
The Darkness · Hot Cakes121
Graham Parker and the Rumour · Three Chords Good106
Ian Hunter · When I'm President103
Breakups · Running Jumping Falling Shouting100
Michael Des Barres · Carnaby Street100
Nada Surf · The Stars Are Indifferent to Astronomy813
Buffalo Killers · Dig Sow Love Grow80
Lucero · Women & Work80

Similar Ballots
.2246Peter Gerstenzang · 2012
.1224Steve Simels · 2012
.1204Mark Keresman · 2012
.0523Bill Holdship · 2012
.0362John Dugan · 2012
.0352Jeff Tamarkin · 2012
.0342Stephen Haag · 2012
.0332Deborah Sprague · 2012
.0332Ethan Covey · 2012
.0332Jim Bessman · 2012
.0322Charles Johnson · 2012
.0322Matt Ryan · 2012
.0312Jay Bennett · 2012
.0312J. R. Taylor · 2012
.0252Mike Rowell · 2012
.0222Bob Ruggiero · 2008
.0222James Barber · 2012
.0222Jim Testa · 2012
.0222Preston Jones · 2011
.0212James Bradley · 2012
.0212Jeff Vrabel · 2011
.0212Kenyon Hopkin · 2011
.0212Thor Christensen · 2011
2011 original ballot
Centricity.087#590 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Wilco · The Whole Love1053
Fountains of Wayne · Sky Full of Holes1017
Mike Viola · Electro de Perfecto102
Blitzen Trapper · American Goldwing101
Howling Diablos · Ultra Sonic Gas Can101
Breakdowns · The Kids Don't Wanna Bop Anymore100
Buffalo Killers · 3100
Leadfinger · We Make the Music100
Refreshments · Riding Along With the Refreshments100
Terry Anderson and the Olympic Ass Kicking Team · More Smooth Jazz and Sweet Sweet Jams100

Similar Ballots
.1134Parke Puterbaugh · 2011
.0704Jim Connelly · 2011
.0403Charles R. Cross · 2011
.0352Matt Gewolb · 2011
.0332Brett Callwood · 2011
.0332Larry King · 2011
.0332Lee Zimmerman · 2011
.0322Andrew Nash · 2011
.0322Edd Hurt · 2011
.0322Steve Simels · 2011
.0252Andrew Hamlin · 2011
.0242Carlo Wolff · 2011
.0242Paul Robicheau · 2011
.0242Steve Matteo · 2011
.0242Thor Christensen · 2011
.0232David Menconi · 2011
.0232Jay Bennett · 2011
.0232John Dugan · 2011
.0232Josh Modell · 2011
.0232Thorin Klosowski · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.011#693 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Jim Jones Revue · Burning Your House Down151
Christine Ohlman and Rebel Montez · The Deep End150
Len Price 3 · Pictures150
Sights · Most of What Follows Is True103
The 88 · The 88101
Grip Weeds · Strange Change Machine101
Mother Truckers · Van Tour100
Edward O'Connell · Our Little Secret50
Farrah · Farrah50
Greenhornes · Four Stars50
SongOther Votes
Cee Lo Green · "Fuck You!"186

Similar Ballots
.0584Christel Loar · 2010
.0422David M Snyder · 2010
.0352Brian Bowe · 2010
.0333Mike Mettler · 2010
.0332Bob Mehr · 2010
.0332Brian Smith · 2010
.0212Chris M. Junior · 2010
.0212L. Kent Wolgamott · 2011
.0192Bob Mehr · 2011
.0172Jed Gottlieb · 2010
.0142Miles Marshall Lewis · 2010
.0132Josh Modell · 2010
.0132Matt Ryan · 2010
.0132Michael Deeds · 2010
.0132Salvatore Caputo · 2011
.0132Steve Simels · 2010
.0122Kevin Moreau · 2010
.0122Milo Miles · 2010
.0122Will Layman · 2010
.0112Bill Forman · 2010
.0112Bill Holdship · 2010
.0112Jason Ferguson · 2010
.0112J. R. Taylor · 2010
.0112Randall Roberts · 2010
.0112Robert Ham · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.035#644 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Reigning Sound · Love and Curses1510
Lions in the Street · Lions in the Street150
Olympic Ass-Kickin Team · National Champions150
Lucero · 1372 Overton Park108
Tinted Windows · Tinted Windows87
Bobby Emmett · Learning Love82
Webb Wilder · More Like Me80
Fastball · Little White Lies71
John Paul Keith and the One Four Fives · Spills and Thrills70
Tripwires · House to House70

Similar Ballots
.1194Jonah Bayer · 2009
.0724Noel Murray · 2009
.0443Christel Loar · 2009
.0432David M Snyder · 2010
.0352Ken Rayes · 2009
.0342Steve Simels · 2009
.0332Deborah Sprague · 2009
.0332Mike Berick · 2009
.0332Stephen Haag · 2009
.0322Fred Mills · 2009
.0272Dan Ferguson · 2009
.0252Marc Hirsh · 2009
.0242Cecile Cloutier · 2009
.0222Brian Smith · 2009
.0222Geoffrey Himes · 2009
.0212Andrew Gilstrap · 2009
.0212Britt Robson · 2009
.0212Chris M. Junior · 2009
.0212Lola Emanuelli · 2009
.0212Mike Mettler · 2009
.0212Noah Bailey · 2009
.0212Scott Mervis · 2009
.0212Will Layman · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.034#539 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Black Crowes · Warpaint205
Marah · Angels of Destruction!151
Whigs · Mission Control108
Foxboro Hot Tubs · Stop Drop and Roll!!!104
Mitch Ryder · You Deserve My Art100
The Odds · Cheerleader100
Quireboys · Homewreckers and Heartbreakers100
Fratellis · Here We Stand51
Love Me Nots · Detroit51
Revisionists · The Revisionists50
SongOther Votes
Whigs · "Like a Vibration"2
Black Crowes · "Goodbye Daughters of the Revolution"1
Supergrass · "Rebel in You"1
Boss Martians · "Elsie"0
Kelly Jones · "There Goes My Baby"0
Kooks · "Shine On"0
Mother Truckers · "Dynamite"0
Paul Collins Beat · "Falling in Love With Her"0
Solution · "Pickin' Wild Mountain Berries"0
Zutons · "What's Your Problem"0

Similar Ballots
.0714John Davidson · 2008
.0292Sean Daly · 2008
.0282Jeff Tamarkin · 2008
.0282Shae Moseley · 2008
.0282Tom Cheyney · 2008
.0272Ben Mitchell · 2008
.0272Bob Ruggiero · 2008
.0272Matt Hickey · 2008
.0272Matt Ryan · 2008
.0272Steve Pick · 2008
.0262Brian Smith · 2008
.0192Chris M. Junior · 2008
.0182Anthony Easton · 2008
.0182David Peisner · 2008
.0182Greg Beets · 2008
.0182Jason Harper · 2008
.0182Lissa Townsend Rodgers · 2008
.0182Ron Hart · 2008
.0182Stephen Thomas Erlewine · 2008
.0172Annie Zaleski · 2008
.0172Dave Gil de Rubio · 2008
.0172Gary Graff · 2008
.0172Jason Gross · 2008
Similar Voters
.09018Steve Simels
.07921Bill Holdship
.07714Peter Gerstenzang
.06812Jim Connelly
.05810Brian Smith
.05511Jeff Tamarkin
.05011Christel Loar
.04911Stephen Haag
.04816L. Kent Wolgamott
.0476Parke Puterbaugh
.04511Mark Deming
.04411Matt Ryan
.04214Chris M. Junior
.04213Dave Gil de Rubio
.04114Stephen Thomas Erlewine
.03611Scott Mervis
.0327Andrew Gilstrap
.03010Philip Martin
.0308Larry King
.0306Matt Hickey
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com