This is a statistical index to the Village Voice Pazz & Jop music critics poll, generated in the process of its tabulation for the last few years.
 
Click any linked column-heading to sort a table by that column. Click any album or song for an artist profile, or any voter for a voter profile.
 
Some explanation of the various esoteric metrics:
Similarity is calculated for albums, songs and artists based on voter overlap, and for ballots and voters based on album+song+artist overlap. The ballot and voter scores are weighted by album/song/artist popularity.
Bill Holdship
Overall
Centricity.225#875 of 1313
Breadth.456#455 of 1329
Metalism.000#442 of 1329
2016 original ballot
Centricity.336#292 of 542
Metalism.000#75 of 550
AlbumPointsOther Votes
David Bowie · Blackstar10208
Leonard Cohen · You Want It Darker1080
Drive-By Truckers · American Band1055
Iggy Pop · Post Pop Depression1029
The Monkees · Good Times!1018
Lady Gaga · Joanne108
Alejandro Escovedo · Burn Something Beautiful105
I Don't Cares · Wild Stab104
Bob Dylan · Fallen Angels102
The Beatles · Live at the Hollywood Bowl100

Similar Ballots
.3178Brian Bowe · 2016
.3118Mark Deming · 2016
.2638Mark J. Lepage · 2016
.2598Larry King · 2016
.2067Charles R. Cross · 2016
.2056Jim Bessman · 2016
.1856Ashley Zlatopolsky · 2016
.1846Jose Davila · 2016
.1796Stephen Slaybaugh · 2016
.1786Brett Callwood · 2016
.1726Adam Gold · 2016
.1708A.D. Amorosi · 2016
.1706Steve Klinge · 2016
.1688Peter Blackstock · 2016
.1676Tim Riley · 2016
.1637Ken Rayes · 2016
.1607Jim Connelly · 2016
.1517L. Kent Wolgamott · 2016
.1437Jon Solomon · 2016
.1367Steve Rosen · 2016
2015 original ballot
Centricity.299#277 of 480
Metalism.000#85 of 483
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Courtney Barnett · Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit10166
Jason Isbell · Something More Than Free1050
Bob Dylan · Shadows in the Night1019
Wilco · Star Wars1019
Bob Dylan · The Cutting Edge 1965-1966109
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds · Chasing Yesterday106
Nellie McKay · My Weekly Reader105
Mavericks · Mono104
Libertines · Anthems for Doomed Youth103
Alan Jackson · Angels and Alcohol100
SongOther Votes
Courtney Barnett · "Pedestrian at Best"52
Courtney Barnett · "Depreston"24
David Bowie · "Blackstar"20
Jason Isbell · "24 Frames"14
Darlene Love · "Forbidden Nights"1
Merle Haggard & Willie Nelson · "It's All Going to Pot"1
Elvis Presley With the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra · "If I Can Dream"0
Libertines · "Heart of the Matter"0
Meghan Trainor · "Dear Future Husband"0
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds · "In the Heat of the Moment"0

Similar Ballots
.1618Leland Rucker · 2015
.1556Charles R. Cross · 2015
.1506Roy Kasten · 2015
.1498Christopher Barton · 2015
.1467Ken Rayes · 2015
.1397Richard Skanse · 2015
.1357Chris Herrington · 2015
.1327Eric Danton · 2015
.1327Gary Graff · 2015
.1287Peter Blackstock · 2015
.1175Larry King · 2015
.1136L. Kent Wolgamott · 2015
.1136Ray Padgett · 2015
.1086Jon Bream · 2015
.1064Preston Jones · 2015
.1046Phil Gallo · 2015
.0994Zeth Lundy · 2015
.0964Jeff Tamarkin · 2015
.0954Max Berry · 2015
.0954Steve Horowitz · 2015
2014 original ballot
Centricity.162#433 of 601
Metalism.000#102 of 612
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Lana Del Rey · Ultraviolence1044
Leonard Cohen · Popular Problems1028
Bob Dylan · The Basement Tapes Complete: the Bootleg Series Vol. 111018
Black Keys · Turn Blue1016
Lucinda Williams · Down Where the Spirit Meets the Bone1016
Tweedy · Sukierae109
Bruce Springsteen · High Hopes107
Hold Steady · Teeth Dreams106
The Empty Hearts · The Empty Hearts103
Billie Joe Armstrong & Norah Jones · Foreverly100
SongOther Votes
Taylor Swift · "Blank Space"58
Pharrell Williams · "Happy"27
Replacements · "Poke Me in My Cage"1
Bob Dylan · "Things We Said Today"0
Tony Bennett & Lady Gaga · "Anything Goes"0

Similar Ballots
.20310Ellis Widner · 2014
.2017Salvatore Caputo · 2014
.1796Charles R. Cross · 2014
.1776Larry King · 2014
.1768Ted Cox · 2014
.1578Bob Grossweiner · 2014
.1558Geoffrey Himes · 2014
.1528Chuck Campbell · 2014
.1435Jeff Tamarkin · 2014
.1257Al Choman · 2014
.1257Arsenio Orteza · 2014
.1217Roy Trakin · 2014
.1197Gary Graff · 2014
.1106Eric Danton · 2014
.1036Josh Timmermann · 2014
.0985Carlo Wolff · 2014
.0974Eric T Miller · 2014
.0974Michael Gallucci · 2014
.0964Tom Finkel · 2014
.0944Michael Ayers · 2014
2013 original ballot
Centricity.232#281 of 453
Metalism.000#115 of 457
AlbumPointsOther Votes
David Bowie · The Next Day1045
Arcade Fire · Reflektor1042
Jason Isbell · Southeastern1033
Eminem · The Marshall Mathers LP 21014
Bob Dylan · Another Self Portrait109
Kings of Leon · Mechanical Bull106
Jake Bugg · Jake Bugg105
Del Lords · Elvis Club103
Aaron Neville · My True Story101
(various artists) · Songs for Slim101
SongOther Votes
Lady Gaga · "Applause"10
Eminem (ft. Rihanna) · "The Monster"6
Lady Gaga · "Gypsy"4
Paul McCartney · "New"2
Bruce Springsteen · "Dream Baby Dream"1
Eminem · "Rhyme or Reason"1
Del Lords · "When the Drugs Kick In"0
Joe Henry · "Taken on the Chin (Songs for Slim Series)"0
Lady Gaga · "Manicure"0
Patterson Hood · "Hate This Town (Songs for Slim Series)"0

Similar Ballots
.20310Bob Grossweiner · 2013
.1778L. Kent Wolgamott · 2013
.1749Gary Graff · 2013
.1636Peter Gerstenzang · 2013
.1596Mark J. Lepage · 2013
.1568Ken Rayes · 2013
.1558Roy Trakin · 2013
.1408Holly Gleason · 2013
.1275Michael Deeds · 2013
.1096Bud Scoppa · 2013
.1096Carol Cooper · 2013
.1076Alex Henderson · 2013
.0984Tom Semioli · 2013
.0976Paul Robicheau · 2013
.0895J. Anthony Ware · 2013
.0835Roy Trakin · 2010
.0795Ross Raihala · 2013
.0784Mark Deming · 2013
.0764Curtis Schieber · 2013
.0745Jennifer Vineyard · 2013
2012 original ballot
Centricity.201#283 of 485
Metalism.000#95 of 493
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Bruce Springsteen · Wrecking Ball1035
Bob Dylan · Tempest1032
Dr. John · Locked Down1031
Neil Young & Crazy Horse · Psychedelic Pill1021
Avett Brothers · The Carpenter1010
Neil Young & Crazy Horse · Americana109
The Beach Boys · That's Why God Made the Radio105
Aimee Mann · Charmer103
Ian Hunter · When I'm President103
Green Day · Uno100
SongOther Votes
Bob Dylan · "Duquesne Whistle"10
The Beach Boys · "That's Why God Made the Radio"8
Rolling Stones · "Doom and Gloom"5
Redd Kross · "Stay Away From Downtown"3
Lana Del Rey · "Blue Jeans"2
Aimee Mann · "Charmer"1
Lana Del Rey · "Video Games"1
Ian Hunter · "When I'm President"0
Neil Young & Crazy Horse · "Get a Job"0
Raveonettes · "She Owns the Streets"0

Similar Ballots
.28212Mike Mettler · 2012
.27912Ken Rayes · 2012
.2217Peter Gerstenzang · 2012
.2039Bob Grossweiner · 2012
.1746Bob Ruggiero · 2012
.1696Jeff Tamarkin · 2012
.1668Roy Trakin · 2012
.1666Steve Simels · 2012
.1658L. Kent Wolgamott · 2012
.1306James Barber · 2012
.1226Larry King · 2012
.1156James Bradley · 2012
.1116Al Choman · 2012
.1056Gustavo Turner · 2012
.1046Mike Greenhaus · 2012
.0984Thor Christensen · 2012
.0974Jose Davila · 2012
.0905Leland Rucker · 2012
.0905Matt Rice · 2012
.0904Scott Mervis · 2012
2011 original ballot
Centricity.238#421 of 693
Metalism.000#140 of 700
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Black Keys · El Camino1053
Wilco · The Whole Love1053
The Decemberists · The King Is Dead1039
Lady Gaga · Born This Way1039
R.E.M. · Collapse Into Now1012
Glen Campbell · Ghost on the Canvas108
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds · Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds107
Rolling Stones · Some Girls (Deluxe Reissue)103
(various artists) · Rave on Buddy Holly102
Jack Oblivian · Rat City101
SongOther Votes
Black Keys · "Lonely Boy"29
Lady Gaga · "The Edge of Glory"22
Lady Gaga · "Born This Way"19
Lady Gaga · "Judas"5
Lucinda Williams · "Buttercup"1
Alan Jackson · "You've Been Lonely Too"0
Black Keys · "Gold on the Ceiling"0
Jim Jones Revue · "High Horse"0
Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds · "The Good Rebel (B-Side)"0
Ron Sexsmith · "Get in Line"0

Similar Ballots
.22510Ken Rayes · 2011
.1746Parke Puterbaugh · 2011
.1676Thor Christensen · 2011
.1648Nicole Frehsee · 2011
.1377Scott Mervis · 2011
.1367Holly George-Warren · 2011
.1357Bud Scoppa · 2011
.1337Al Choman · 2011
.1327Roy Trakin · 2011
.1297Jim Tremayne · 2011
.1287Bob Grossweiner · 2011
.1267Richard Skanse · 2011
.1257Daniel Durchholz · 2011
.1076Charles R. Cross · 2011
.1076Gary Graff · 2011
.1076L. Kent Wolgamott · 2011
.1046Jed Gottlieb · 2011
.0905Matthew Perpetua · 2011
.0895Bob Mehr · 2011
.0894Jeff Vrabel · 2011
2010 original ballot
Centricity.204#440 of 699
Metalism.000#121 of 712
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Arcade Fire · The Suburbs10144
Bruce Springsteen · The Promise1033
MGMT · Congratulations1022
Eminem · Recovery1019
Roky Erickson & Okkervil River · True Love Cast Out All Evil1015
Band of Horses · Infinite Arms1012
Midlake · The Courage of Others107
Alejandro Escovedo · Street Songs of Love104
Sadies · Darker Circles104
Yukon Blonde · Yukon Blonde100
SongOther Votes
Cee Lo Green · "Fuck You!"186
Eminem (ft. Rihanna) · "Love the Way You Lie"27
Eminem · "Not Afraid"10
MGMT · "Congratulations"4
Bruce Springsteen · "Save My Love"0

Similar Ballots
.2808Mark J. Lepage · 2010
.25911Roy Trakin · 2010
.2288Steve Simels · 2010
.2128Carlo Wolff · 2010
.20910Gary Graff · 2010
.1798Steve Baltin · 2010
.1638Holly Gleason · 2010
.1606Michael Deeds · 2010
.1558Bob Grossweiner · 2010
.1346David A Cobb · 2010
.1337Adam Gold · 2010
.1256Raquel Cepeda-Jenkins · 2010
.1176Evan Serpick · 2010
.1156Bill O'Neill · 2010
.1156Bud Scoppa · 2010
.1136Bob Townsend · 2010
.1094Matt Gewolb · 2010
.1086Michael Gallucci · 2010
.1076Derek Paiva · 2010
.1076Jon Bream · 2010
2009 original ballot
Centricity.171#436 of 683
Metalism.000#161 of 697
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Wilco · Wilco (The Album)1043
Green Day · 21st Century Breakdown1025
Rosanne Cash · The List1023
Bruce Springsteen · Working on a Dream1018
Raveonettes · In and Out of Control1013
Glasvegas · Glasvegas1011
New York Dolls · 'Cause I Sez So1010
Cheap Trick · The Latest106
Eminem · Relapse106
John Doe and the Sadies · Country Club102

Similar Ballots
.2016Peter Gerstenzang · 2009
.1946Steve Simels · 2009
.1537L. Kent Wolgamott · 2009
.1276Jason MacNeil · 2009
.1226Derek Paiva · 2009
.1224Jim Sullivan · 2009
.1204Brett Callwood · 2009
.1184Jeff Tamarkin · 2009
.1164Jim Bessman · 2009
.1134Jed Gottlieb · 2009
.1124Meredith Ochs · 2009
.1114David Adler · 2009
.1114Ken Rayes · 2009
.1114Steve Baltin · 2009
.1104Rick Petreycik · 2009
.1074Derk Richardson · 2009
.1074Holly George-Warren · 2009
.0994Larry King · 2009
.0834Jud Cost · 2009
.0774David Downs · 2009
2008 original ballot
Centricity.179#384 of 568
Metalism.000#123 of 579
AlbumPointsOther Votes
Bob Dylan · The Bootleg Series, Vol. 8: Tell Tale Signs - Rare and Unreleased 1989-20061035
R.E.M. · Accelerate1028
Kings of Leon · Only by the Night1023
Alejandro Escovedo · Real Animal1022
Raconteurs · Consolers of the Lonely1016
Brian Wilson · That Lucky Old Sun106
The Fireman · Electric Arguments105
Rodriguez · Cold Fact105
Kooks · Konk104
Paul Westerberg · 49:00104
SongOther Votes
Coldplay · "Viva la Vida"38
Pink · "So What"19
Kings of Leon · "Sex on Fire"15
Weezer · "Pork and Beans"11
R.E.M. · "Man-Sized Wreath"1

Similar Ballots
.1886Thor Christensen · 2008
.1866Rick Petreycik · 2008
.1796David Fricke · 2008
.1594Ben Lukoff · 2008
.1527Roy Trakin · 2008
.1386Preston Jones · 2008
.1375Bob Grossweiner · 2008
.1337George A. Paul · 2008
.1236Chris M. Junior · 2008
.1156Melissa Ruggieri · 2008
.1156Whitney Pastorek · 2008
.1154David Menconi · 2008
.1136Edna Gundersen · 2008
.1136Glenn Gamboa · 2008
.1126Ken Rayes · 2008
.1124Parke Puterbaugh · 2008
.1114Steve Kandell · 2008
.1075Larry King · 2008
.1074Mark J. Lepage · 2008
.1074Spencer Kaufman · 2008
Similar Voters
.21157Ken Rayes
.18757Roy Trakin
.18051Bob Grossweiner
.17235Mark J. Lepage
.16930Peter Gerstenzang
.16051L. Kent Wolgamott
.14852Gary Graff
.14128Jeff Tamarkin
.13634Charles R. Cross
.13632Al Choman
.13442Holly Gleason
.13327Steve Simels
.12718Carlo Wolff
.12631Larry King
.12337Jon Bream
.11718Thor Christensen
.11625Holly George-Warren
.11320David Menconi
.11232Philip Martin
.10915Salvatore Caputo
Poll administered by the Village Voice  ·  Tabulation and analysis by glenn mcdonald / furia.com